Lunchboxes — Poem analysis

Henrietta ClarkeContemplative

Lunchboxes must be filled ....

In golden-shaded afternoons in Spring, when children laugh and play across the square, the mothers are at home, and with a skill that comes from years of patient toil and care, they quickly make up lunches for their men.

Nearing midnight, with half the world asleep, when strange night noises pass along the narrow street; before the whistle blows, to break the quiet with voice blatant and strong, tired women give to this small task their best.

At early dawn before the sky is settled and soft new eager morning sounds are heard; the clop-clop of the milkman's ancient horse, the gentle flutelike notes of some small bird, the women of the house are busy then. Lunchboxes must be filled.

And deep down in the mine, or by the light of molten slag, men eat and are content.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Few poems about work begin by looking away from the workplace. Henrietta Clarke's "Lunchboxes" opens in a kitchen, not a mine, and the whole poem is a quiet argument about where industrial labour really begins. The men who go underground or stand beside "molten slag" appear only in the final two lines. Everything before them belongs to the women who make the working day possible.

The poem is built as a cycle of three scenes, each pinned to a different hour: a spring afternoon, nearly midnight, early dawn. These times seem scattered, even contradictory, until we realise what the poem is hinting at. The men presumably work in shifts, so the lunches are needed at every hour, and the women's task has no fixed beginning or end. A day shift, a night shift, an early start: the box must be ready for each. The refrain that brackets the poem, "Lunchboxes must be filled", works like a clock striking. It sounds like an instruction, almost a law, and the passive construction matters. Nobody is named as the one who fills them; the obligation simply exists, and the women absorb it.

Clarke gives each scene its own texture. The afternoon is all brightness: "golden-shaded", children laughing across the square. Here the work looks almost pleasant, done "with a skill / that comes from years of patient toil and care." But notice that single word "toil" slipping into the sunlit picture. The midnight scene darkens the mood. "Strange night noises" move along a "narrow street", and the women are "tired", the only place in the poem where exhaustion is stated outright. Even so, they "give to this small task their best." The word "small" is the poem's quiet irony. The task is described as small while it consumes afternoons, midnights and dawns, and the women give it their best anyway.

The dawn stanza is the richest in imagery, and it is the most tender. The sky is "not settled", the morning sounds are "soft" and "eager", and we hear the "clop-clop" of the milkman's "ancient horse" and the "gentle flutelike notes of some small bird." The onomatopoeia of "clop-clop" gives the passage a slow, homely rhythm, while the bird's flute-like song lifts it toward something almost musical. It is a world of gentleness, and the women are awake inside it, "busy then." Their labour is placed within the beauty of the morning rather than set against it, which makes it feel both natural and invisible.

The poem does not rely on rhyme in any strict way. There are faint echoes, such as "care" and "square" in the first stanza, and "heard" and "bird" in the third, but the pattern is loose, and the lines vary in length. This looseness suits the subject. A tightly rhymed poem would sound ceremonious; Clarke's gentle, uneven lines sound more like the real rhythm of housework, steady but never quite finished. The stanzas also grow longer as the poem moves toward dawn, as if the work expands to fill whatever time is available.

The ending turns on a sharp contrast of scale and place. After the long, unhurried stanzas, we get just two lines, and they leap from the sleeping house to the depths of the earth: "deep down in the mine, or by the light / of molten slag, men eat and are content." The women's whole night of effort is compressed into one image of men eating. "Content" is the final word, and it is deliberately ambiguous. It could be sincere gratitude, or it could suggest that the men never consider what stands behind the meal. The poem does not accuse anyone. It simply lets the reader notice that the contentment travels in one direction, while the work travels in the other.

What makes "Lunchboxes" worth reading is this restraint. It contains no complaint and no speech, only a pattern of repeated, careful actions. By showing so much attention given to a "small task", the poem makes us see how much of the world's hard labour rests on work that is rarely counted as work at all.

Read also

More by Henrietta Clarke

All poems
DreamyHenrietta Clarke

Mirage

Away in the Southland, Spring came early, And flowers blossomed overnight; This should have made my heart beat faster, As I gazed in awe at the magic sight.
InspiredHenrietta Clarke

Fall Ploughing

The men who plough in Springtime see Small growing things 'ere long, But men who plough in Autumntime Must have great faith and strong.
ContemplativeHenrietta Clarke

Resignation

The old tree was to be cut down; for years it had stood among its green neighbors conspicuous by its lack of verdure, with hoary moss on grey flanks, and