Fit Remembrance — Poem analysis

I. L. SalomonContemplative

I should not want the quarried slate Or granite to perpetuate My memory when I am gone. It is not fit. I fought with stone Too long to have its weight upon The locked earth underneath whose sod I measure less than half a rod.

To know I was, may my bones be Tied to the anonymity Of hidden roots so intertwined The man I was becomes defined In one tall maple tree whose shade Falls gratefully where I am laid.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Most epitaph poems ask to be remembered loudly. "Fit Remembrance" asks to be remembered quietly, and then goes further: it asks to be remembered as something other than a person at all. The speaker, imagining his own death, rejects the traditional memorial of "quarried slate / Or granite" and proposes instead that his body feed the roots of a maple tree. What he wants is not a monument but a transformation, and the poem's central idea is that the most honest kind of immortality might be the one that costs the world nothing and gives it shade.

The reasoning begins with a striking confession in the first stanza: "I fought with stone / Too long to have its weight upon / The locked earth." The poem never says who this man was or what his stone-fighting involved, and it would be a mistake to invent a biography for him. But the phrase suggests a life of hard, resistant labor, perhaps literally with rock, perhaps figuratively with a stubborn world. Either way, the logic is moving in its simplicity: he has spent enough of his life pushing against stone, so he refuses to lie under it. Notice, too, how the grave is described. The earth is "locked," and he will "measure less than half a rod," a surveyor's unit that shrinks a whole life to a few feet of ground. The measuring language is dry, almost bureaucratic, and that dryness is the point. He is not grieving over his own death; he is calmly taking its dimensions.

The form supports this calm. The poem is written in tight rhymed couplets (slate/perpetuate, gone/stone/upon) and in steady, short lines that sound close to four-beat iambic verse. The first stanza gathers an unusual three-rhyme run on "gone," "stone" and "upon," with the stone rhyme landing exactly where the speaker mentions his old adversary. The sound itself feels heavy and closed, like a lid. Then the final line of that stanza breaks the pattern, rhyming "sod" with "rod" in a pair that stays visibly separate from the earlier trio, a small formal gesture that echoes the narrowness of the grave. The second stanza, shorter and looser in its movement, trades that sealed-in quality for something more open, as if the sentences themselves were growing.

That growth is the poem's finest imaginative move. The key words of the second stanza are about dissolving and then re-emerging. His bones will be "tied to the anonymity / Of hidden roots," and the word "tied" is quietly paradoxical: it sounds like binding, yet it describes freedom from the isolation of a headstone. "Anonymity" might seem like an odd thing to ask for in a poem about remembrance, but the speaker redefines the term. He will not be a name carved on a surface; instead the man "becomes defined / In one tall maple tree." The verb "defined" is the poem's sharpest irony, because definition usually means a boundary or a label, and here it means taking the living shape of a tree.

The last two lines complete the thought gently. The tree's shade "Falls gratefully where I am laid." The adverb is worth pausing on. Shade does not usually feel gratitude, so the word transfers the feeling to the scene, or perhaps to the speaker himself, who finds in this small mercy a fitting kind of fame. The remembrance he wants is useful rather than ornamental: shade for whoever happens to stand there.

What makes the poem significant is how much argument it packs into twelve short lines. It challenges the assumption that being remembered means being marked, and it does so without bitterness or showy philosophy. Its title carries the whole debate in a single word: "fit" means both suitable and healthy, as in a living thing. The speaker's wish is to be fitted back into the cycle of growth, and the poem's plain language and neat rhymes make that wish feel not grim but reasonable, even generous.

Read also

More by I. L. Salomon

All poems
AnxiousI. L. Salomon

Ballad for a Coal-Black Tom

The coal-black cat and the chipmunk sat, A verandah's length between them; All stillness crouched in a feline frame, The cat was slick as the chipmunk tame,
ContemplativeI. L. Salomon

I Lie Alone

I lie alone: I breathe, I think, I dream. I wake in nightmare at the dawn of sleep To silences unspeakable as noise Filtrating solitude that has me creep
CheerfulI. L. Salomon

Birdsong for Rain

The familiar birds were calling for water, Their unlabored watersong crying for rain, As the unmeditated summer heat Sank in thick swathes on the tumbled grain.