Mendicant — Poem analysis

Louise LouisContemplative

Lean on my shoulder, ragged, borne upon a crutch . . . yet lean.

I do not ask your travelings; long ago I learned all journeyings are secret since none may know the end till he arrives.

Rest. For every ditch has mirrors; the spheres will shine and swing in them with tantalizing nearness to your cheek. So far from Heaven it is to lie upon the reflection of a star . . .

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A beggar limps along a road, and someone, the speaker, offers a shoulder. That is the whole event of "Mendicant," and yet the poem opens out into something larger than an act of charity. It becomes a meditation on how little we can know about anyone else's life, and on the odd closeness of the sublime to the squalid. About the poet, Louise Louis, I can say nothing reliable, so everything here rests on what the words themselves do.

Start with the first three lines. The beggar is "ragged, / borne upon a crutch," and the speaker's invitation arrives in a command: "Lean on my shoulder." Then comes the poem's quietest turn: "yet lean." That one-word line, set apart on its own, answers an unspoken objection. The "yet" implies that the beggar is reluctant, perhaps proud, perhaps already supported by the crutch and wary of needing more. The speaker's repetition of the verb is gentle but insistent, like someone holding a door open a second time.

The second stanza explains why the speaker asks no questions. "I do not ask your travelings; / long ago I learned / all journeyings are secret / since none may know the end / till he arrives." The logic is neat and a little startling. We usually think of a journey as secret because the traveler hides it. Here it is secret because even the traveler cannot know where it leads. A mendicant, a wandering beggar, is a figure of pure travel without a fixed destination, so the word carries real weight. The phrase "long ago I learned" suggests hard-won experience, as if the speaker has also been on some road and has stopped demanding explanations from anyone, themselves included. Notice too how the lines grow slightly longer and more flowing here, mimicking the unhurried walk the speaker is trying to share.

The final stanza is where the poem's imagery lifts. "Rest," the speaker says, a single word again, now a plain invitation rather than a command. Then comes a surprise: "every ditch has mirrors." A ditch is the lowest, muddiest place a roadside offers, the place where a tired traveler might collapse. Yet it holds water, and the water holds the sky. "The spheres will shine and swing / in them with tantalizing nearness / to your cheek." The verbs are lovely: stars do not merely appear, they "swing," as if the reflected heavens were gently rocking. "Tantalizing" is a sharp word choice, since it recalls the myth of a man forever reaching for what he cannot grasp. The stars sit near enough to touch the beggar's face and yet remain, in reality, impossibly far.

That tension is resolved in the last line, which is the poem's most interesting. "So far from Heaven it is / to lie upon the reflection of a star." On a quick reading this sounds like a sigh of distance: the beggar is far from heaven. But the phrasing can be turned the other way. To lie on a reflected star is to be, almost literally, resting on the heavens, so perhaps heaven is not so far after all. The poem leaves the question open, and the trailing ellipsis, which echoes the one in the opening stanza, lets the thought hang rather than close. We are never told whether the beggar finds comfort, only that comfort is offered.

Structurally the poem is free verse. There is no regular rhyme scheme and no fixed metre, which suits its subject, since a poem about unmapped roads would feel odd marching in strict formation. Instead the music comes from short, hushed lines and from repeated sounds, such as the soft l's of "lean," "long," "learned," "mirrors," and "tantalizing," which give the whole piece a murmuring, lulling quality.

What makes "Mendicant" worth reading is its restraint. It never lectures about kindness or poverty. It offers a shoulder, withholds judgment, and trusts a puddle of starlight to do the rest.

Read also

More by Louise Louis

All poems
CheerfulLouise Louis

Jay

He kicked the brush and let a small rock skip doing a dusty dance ahead of him; then finding it before his feet
ContemplativeLouise Louis

Soothsayer

What is it yesterday told? What will tomorrow relate? "Distance but lies in your heart." "Today moves her tent while you wait."
InspiredLouise Louis

Always Renaissance

It's the beginning again . . . that is brave! From the cloistered grave silence of winter come tumbling