City of the Heart — Poem analysis

I have been through the gates of an old city, Girt round by walls of gray and mellow stone, Whose streets were filled with strong, clear golden light; The shade of towering trees; and many flowers, As richly fragrant and as brightly dyed As I had ever known; and there was music, Spilled by the wind among the murmuring leaves, And from the throats of birds whose gay wings brushed A sky of burnished blue with streaks of song.

I stood beside a lake of crystal waters That shimmed with the splendor of drowned sun, And listened to the bells sing Angelus From the high spires of a white cathedral: And there was wonder in me, for I had Never before beheld — nor even dreamed of! — Such a city, beautiful and serene, Built from wisdom and with tenderness, Within the tiny compass of your heart.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

For most of its length, "City of the Heart" reads like a traveller's account of somewhere wonderful. The speaker passes through the gates of an old walled city, wanders its sunlit streets, and ends up beside a lake, listening to cathedral bells. Only in the last line does the poem turn and tell us where all this was. The city lies "within the tiny compass of your heart." That final phrase changes how everything before it should be read. The golden streets and singing birds were never a place on a map. They describe what it is like to discover, in another person, a depth of goodness that the speaker had never imagined.

The poem is built to make that discovery feel like a surprise. Its sentences are long and unhurried. The first stanza is one extended movement, carried from line to line without full stops, so that the reader strolls through the gates and keeps walking, much as the speaker does. The poem is written in blank verse, unrhymed lines that run close to the natural beat of ten syllables, an iambic pentameter that sounds like speech without ever becoming casual. The absence of rhyme suits the subject, since nothing here feels engineered or forced. The calm, steady rhythm mirrors the "serene" quality the speaker eventually names. Even the small interruptions, such as the semicolon after "golden light" and the dash in "nor even dreamed of!", feel like moments where the speaker catches his breath.

The imagery is almost entirely of light, sound and scent, and it is generous to the point of abundance. The light is "strong, clear golden light," the sky a "burnished blue," the lake a mirror for the "splendor of drowned sun." The flowers are "richly fragrant" and "brightly dyed," while music arrives from two directions: the wind "spilled" among leaves, and birds whose wings brush the sky with "streaks of song." That last image is the most inventive in the poem. It treats birdsong as paint, something that can be streaked across the blue, so that sound and sight merge. The verb "spilled" does similar work, suggesting music that is not performed but simply overflows, too plentiful to be contained.

Several word choices carry the poem's moral weight quietly. The city is "old," which suggests something tested and lasting rather than newly built. Its walls are "gray and mellow stone," a phrase that sets age and warmth side by side. The walls "girt round" the city, protective rather than forbidding, and the speaker walks through the gates freely. The lake is "crystal," a word suggesting clarity and honesty, nothing murky or concealed. Then there is the Angelus, the bell that traditionally marks moments of daily prayer, sung from a "white cathedral." Without preaching, the poem lets a sense of the sacred settle over the scene, so that the heart it describes is something close to a holy place.

The final lines explain what the city is made of: it is "built from wisdom and with tenderness." The grammar is worth noticing. The city is built from wisdom but with tenderness, as though one supplies the material and the other the manner. Good character, the poem implies, needs both the knowing and the gentleness in how that knowledge is used. The speaker's reaction, "wonder," is also carefully chosen. He does not claim to have earned the city or to understand it. He has simply been allowed in.

What makes the poem worth reading is its inversion of scale. The word "tiny" in the last line sets a whole city of cathedral spires, lakes and woods inside a single human heart. It is a compliment, but a more thoughtful one than most, because it suggests that a person's inner life can be larger, richer and more beautiful than anything visible from the outside. The poem's closing gesture is also an invitation: the "you" at the end is anyone, including the reader, who might turn out to hold such a place within.

Read also

More by Robert Smithdas

All poems
ContemplativeRobert Smithdas

Hero

In dreams I climb Mount Everest, And plant a banner on its crest; Or plunge through thrashing, storm-swept waves To seek drowned gold in coral caves;
SadRobert Smithdas

Ghost Town

No one recalls who built these leaning walls And sagging roofs along this mountainside; Here silence fills the hollows of the hills, Where once the sound of laughter lived and died.
RomanticRobert Smithdas

A Pair of Blue Eyes

I remember seeing, somewhere in a crowd, A pair of blue and candid smiling eyes, Filled with bright light, and calm serenity, And gazing out upon the world of change