The Word — Poem analysis

Edward ThomasContemplative

THERE are so many things I have forgot, That once were much to me, or that were not, All lost, as is a childless woman's child And its child's children, in the undefiled Abyss of what can never be again. I have forgot, too, names of the mighty men That fought and lost or won in the old wars, Of kings and fiends and gods, and most of the stars. Some things I have forgot that I forget. But lesser things there are, remembered yet, Than all the others. One name that I have not-- Though 'tis an empty thingless name--forgot Never can die because Spring after Spring Some thrushes learn to say it as they sing. There is always one at midday saying it clear And tart--the name, only the name I hear. While perhaps I am thinking of the elder scent That is like food, or while I am content With the wild rose scent that is like memory, This name suddenly is cried out to me From somewhere in the bushes by a bird Over and over again, a pure thrush word.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Most poems about memory try to rescue something. Edward Thomas begins by letting nearly everything go. The speaker admits to a long list of losses: things that "once were much to me, or that were not," the names of "mighty men / That fought and lost or won in the old wars," even "most of the stars." Then the poem turns. One name survives, and it survives not because he has held on to it but because every spring the thrushes sing it. The central idea is that some memories are not kept in the mind at all. The living world renews them.

The opening images make forgetting feel enormous and strangely clean. A lost thing is compared to "a childless woman's child / And its child's children", a whole line of descendants who never existed, swallowed by an "undefiled / Abyss of what can never be again." Then comes the dry, almost comic admission "Some things I have forgot that I forget," where the speaker has lost even the awareness of the gap. The things he has let slip are grand ones, "kings and fiends and gods," so the "lesser things" that remain look all the more modest and stubborn beside them.

The form suits this quiet confession. The poem is a single block of rhyming couplets, twenty-two lines with no breaks, and the lines have roughly five beats each, loosening here and there into a spoken, almost galloping rhythm ("There is always one at midday saying it clear"). Some rhymes are relaxed enough to sound like conversation: "again" with "men," and "memory" with "me," where the second word is so light it barely lands. The syntax is where the poem stumbles most. The sentence about the one surviving name wanders through a dash and an aside ("Though 'tis an empty thingless name") before "forgot" turns up at the end of a line, almost too late. The rhyme of "not" and "forgot" makes the verse trip over the very thing it cannot hold. The last couplet, "bird" and "word," brings the title home with a click.

What the word actually is, we never learn. Thomas calls it "an empty thingless name," a label attached to nothing, and the poem withholds it. The reader is left where the speaker is, hearing a sound with no explanation. The thrush has no use for meaning. It simply repeats, "Over and over again," and the line's own insistent rhythm echoes that repetition.

Thomas also blurs the senses. The thrush's call is "clear / And tart," a taste applied to a sound. The elder scent is "like food," and the wild rose scent is "like memory," which suggests memory here is something breathed in and tasted rather than thought. The name arrives without effort or warning: it "is cried out to me / From somewhere in the bushes." The grammar is passive, the bird is unseen, and the speaker does not recall anything. Something is delivered to him while he is thinking of flowers or simply "content."

The ending also answers the opening. The abyss was "undefiled," and the last line gives us "a pure thrush word." Oblivion and birdsong are both described as clean, as if the poem had found its one fixed point in a world where kings, gods and even stars slip away. The word that lasts is the one with no history and no ambition, a sound older than names.

That is why the poem matters. It reverses the usual picture of memory as a private store we must guard, and it suggests that what endures may be what is least important in worldly terms. Knowing that Thomas himself was killed in the First World War adds a faint shadow to the lines about forgotten fighters, though the poem never says so. Its comfort is small and seasonal: the names of the mighty can vanish, but in spring a thrush in the bushes will still be saying something, clearly, over and over.

Read also

More by Edward Thomas

All poems
AnxiousEdward Thomas

The New House

Now first, as I shut the door, I was alone In the new house; and the wind Began to moan.
ContemplativeEdward Thomas

Tears

IT seems I have no tears left. They should have fallen-- Their ghosts, if tears have ghosts, did fall--that day When twenty hounds streamed by me, not yet combed out
AnxiousEdward Thomas

Out in the Dark

OUT in the dark over the snow The fallow fawns invisible go With the fallow doe; And the winds blow