Within the Circuit of This Plodding Life — Poem analysis

Henry David ThoreauContemplative

Within the circuit of this plodding life There enter moments of an azure hue, Untarnished fair as is the violet Or anemone, when the spring strews them By some meandering rivulet, which make The best philosophy untrue that aims But to console man for his grievances I have remembered when the winter came, High in my chamber in the frosty nights, When in the still light of the cheerful moon, On every twig and rail and jutting spout, The icy spears were adding to their length Against the arrows of the coming sun, How in the shimmering noon of summer past Some unrecorded beam slanted across The upland pastures where the Johnswort grew; Or heard, amid the verdure of my mind, The bee's long smothered hum, on the blue flag Loitering amidst the mead; or busy rill, Which now through all its course stands still and dumb Its own memorial,—purling at its play Along the slopes, and through the meadows next, Until its youthful sound was hushed at last In the staid current of the lowland stream; Or seen the furrows shine but late upturned, And where the fieldfare followed in the rear, When all the fields around lay bound and hoar Beneath a thick integument of snow. So by God's cheap economy made rich To go upon my winter's task again.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Thoreau, best known for the prose of *Walden*, opens this poem with a word that sounds like a sigh: "plodding." Life is a "circuit," a round of repeated steps, and into it "There enter moments of an azure hue." The verb matters. These moments aren't earned or scheduled. They enter, like visitors. Their purity is compared to violets or anemones scattered beside a "meandering rivulet," images of unforced, wandering beauty set against the plodding walk of the first line.

The next claim is the boldest. Such moments "make / The best philosophy untrue that aims / But to console man for his grievances." The poem seems to say that a philosophy built only to soothe us is shown up by joy itself. Consolation treats life as a stock of troubles to be eased, while the azure moments suggest a surplus, something given rather than something repaid. That is my reading of a compressed passage, but the rest of the poem backs it up, because what follows is a demonstration rather than an argument.

The speaker is "High in my chamber in the frosty nights," watching moonlit ice. Even the winter here is sharply seen. Icicles are "spears" lengthening "Against the arrows of the coming sun," a small war between cold and light in which the sun's victory is already guaranteed. Then memory takes over, and the sentence stretches across almost twenty lines. The syntax drifts the way remembering does. One recollection is introduced with "How," and the next two follow with "Or heard" and "Or seen," as if the mind were turning over summer objects one at a time. First comes "Some unrecorded beam" slanting over pastures where Johnswort grew, a light nobody wrote down at the time, yet it survived. Then comes the bee's hum on the blue flag, a flower whose name quietly echoes the earlier "azure." Finally there are the freshly turned furrows, shining, with a fieldfare following behind.

The sound words are especially good. The bee's hum is "long smothered," muffled by the season but still audible "amid the verdure of my mind." The phrase puts greenery inside the head while snow lies outside. The brook is even more striking. In winter it "stands still and dumb / Its own memorial," a frozen stream that has become its own monument. But the speaker remembers it "purling at its play," and then its "youthful sound" grows "hushed at last / In the staid current of the lowland stream." Judging by the language, the rill's course also reads as a small life story, from playful youth to sober, settled maturity. That adds an undertone of time passing to what could have been a simple nature sketch.

Formally, the poem is blank verse, unrhymed lines of roughly ten syllables with a loose iambic beat. This suits it. Rhyme would chime and close each thought, while blank verse lets the sentences run on. Lines break in the middle of ideas ("which make / The best philosophy untrue"), so the reader is pulled forward just as the speaker is pulled backward into memory. Vocabulary shifts between plain Anglo-Saxon words ("hum," "rill," "snow") and learned Latinate ones ("integument" for the snow's covering), which gives the winter a faintly heavy, official feel.

The ending is the quietest part. "So by God's cheap economy made rich / To go upon my winter's task again." The phrase "cheap economy" is a paradox. The beam, the bee and the brook cost nothing, yet they enrich. And the poem doesn't finish in rapture. It finishes with a return to work, and the last word, "again," closes the circuit that the opening described. Life is still a round, but it is no longer merely plodding.

What makes the poem worth reading is that it refuses two easy options. It doesn't pretend winter is pleasant, and it doesn't offer a comforting lesson. It makes a practical claim instead: stored-up beauty is real wealth, and a person can live on it. The poem makes that case through exact, humble details, a Johnswort field, a bee, a bird in a furrow, which is probably why it persuades.

Read also

More by Henry David Thoreau

All poems
ContemplativeHenry David Thoreau

Prayer

Great God, I ask for no meaner pelf Than that I may not disappoint myself, That in my action I may soar as high As I can now discern with this clear eye.
ContemplativeHenry David Thoreau

The Moon

Time wears her not; she doth his chariot guide; Mortality below her orb is placed. --Raleigh The full-orbed moon with unchanged ray
CheerfulHenry David Thoreau

The Summer Rain

My books I'd fain cast off, I cannot read, 'Twixt every page my thoughts go stray at large Down in the meadow, where is richer feed, And will not mind to hit their proper targe.