TO PRIMROSES FILLED WITH MORNING DEW — Poem analysis

Robert HerrickContemplative

Why do ye weep, sweet babes? can tears Speak grief in you, Who were but born just as the modest morn Teem'd her refreshing dew? Alas, you have not known that shower That mars a flower, Nor felt th' unkind Breath of a blasting wind, Nor are ye worn with years; Or warp'd as we, Who think it strange to see, Such pretty flowers, like to orphans young, To speak by tears, before ye have a tongue.

Speak, whimp'ring younglings, and make known The reason why Ye droop and weep; Is it for want of sleep, Or childish lullaby? Or that ye have not seen as yet The violet? Or brought a kiss From that Sweet-heart, to this? --No, no, this sorrow shown By your tears shed, Would have this lecture read, That things of greatest, so of meanest worth, Conceived with grief are, and with tears brought forth.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Dew on a flower is an ordinary sight, but Robert Herrick looks at it and sees a nursery full of crying infants. Walking among primroses in the early morning, the speaker asks them, with mock-worried tenderness, "Why do ye weep, sweet babes?" The question is half joke, half puzzlement, because by his own reasoning the flowers have nothing to cry about. They were "but born / just as the modest morn / Teem'd her refreshing dew." They have never met "that shower / That mars a flower" or the "blasting wind," and they are not "worn with years" or "warp'd" like adults. Grief belongs to those with a past. Yet here are tears, shed "before ye have a tongue."

The second stanza turns detective. The speaker runs through guesses as a parent might with a fretful baby: is it lack of sleep, or a missing "childish lullaby"? Then the guesses drift from the nursery towards romance. Perhaps the primroses haven't yet seen "the violet," or received a kiss "From that Sweet-heart, to this." Judging by the context, the "Sweet-heart" is another flower, probably the violet. The playful list builds momentum so that the abrupt "--No, no" lands with a jolt. The speaker drops the game and gives the answer. The tears are a "lecture," a lesson that "things of greatest, so of meanest worth, / Conceived with grief are, and with tears brought forth."

That last line is the poem's central idea. Everything, grand or humble, begins in pain, and the primrose is simply honest about it. The vocabulary of birth has been there from the start. "Teem'd" can mean poured out, but it also carries the sense of bearing offspring, so the morning is a kind of mother and the dew her child. By the end, "conceived" and "brought forth" make the comparison explicit. A newborn's cry is its first language, a way of speaking before it has words, which is exactly what the speaker finds strange in the flowers.

The form quietly supports this. Each stanza has fourteen lines and the same rhyme pattern: a b c c b d d e e a f f g g. The repetition makes the second stanza feel like an answer to the first. In both, the lines start long and then shrink to two or three beats: "Speak grief in you," "Who were but born," "Ye droop and weep." These short lines read like catches of breath, as if the poem were hiccuping through its own small sobs, though that is an interpretation rather than a certainty. Both stanzas then settle into a pair of full-length lines (young/tongue, worth/forth). The first couplet states the oddity and the second explains it. The rhymes sometimes pair ideas too: "morn" with "born," "weep" with "sleep," and "shed" with "read," where the tears become something to be read like a text.

The word choice sets innocence against experience. The flowers are "babes," "younglings," "whimp'ring," "pretty," and even "orphans young," a phrase that adds a note of loneliness, as though the newborn is already on its own. Against these soft words stand harsh ones: "mars," "blasting," "warp'd." The word "warp'd" is the most telling, because the speaker includes himself ("as we"). Adults find the flowers' tears strange only because they have forgotten that sorrow comes first. "Lecture" is a wry choice too. It is a stiff, schoolroom word for a drop of dew, and it makes the flowers the teachers and the poet the student.

The poem is significant for how much it does in so small a space. A tiny natural detail becomes a general truth, and the move from teasing to seriousness is handled without losing charm. The ending is neither gloomy nor sentimental. The tears are not a warning of doom but a sign of how any life starts, a shared beginning for the "greatest" and the "meanest" alike.

Read also

More by Robert Herrick

All poems
SadRobert Herrick

UPON A CHILD

Here a pretty baby lies Sung asleep with lullabies; Pray be silent, and not stir Th' easy earth that covers her.
RomanticRobert Herrick

ART ABOVE NATURE: TO JULIA

When I behold a forest spread With silken trees upon thy head; And when I see that other dress Of flowers set in comeliness;
CheerfulRobert Herrick

TO ENJOY THE TIME

While fates permit us, let's be merry; Pass all we must the fatal ferry; And this our life, too, whirls away, With the rotation of the day.