Sonnet XVII: His Mother Dear Cupid — Poem analysis

His mother dear Cupid offended late, Because that Mars grown slacker in her love, With pricking shot he did not throughly more To keep the pace of their first loving state.

The boy refus'd for fear of Mars's hate, Who threaten'd stripes, if he his wrath did prove: But she in chafe him from her lap did shove, Brake bow, brake shafts, while Cupid weeping sate:

Till that his grandame Nature pityijng it Of stella's brows make him two better bows, And in her eyes of arrows infinite.

Oh how for joy he leaps, oh how he crows, And straight therewith like wags new got to play, Falls to shrewd turns, and I was in his way.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Cupid gets shoved off his mother's lap, sits weeping among his broken toys, and is rescued just in time to ruin the speaker's life. Sidney's sonnet, from his sequence *Astrophil and Stella*, turns a love complaint into a small family comedy among the gods, and the sting arrives only in its last six words.

The story is told as a household quarrel. Cupid's mother (Venus, though the poem never names her) is annoyed because Mars has grown "slacker in her love". She wants her son to fire an arrow that will revive his affection, but the boy refuses, afraid of Mars, who "threaten'd stripes", meaning a whipping. Venus loses her temper, "in chafe", and breaks his bow and arrows. The gods are bickering parents and a frightened child, and Sidney's wit lies in how ordinary he makes them. Even the syntax plays along. "His mother dear Cupid offended late" delays the subject until we are halfway through the line, so for a moment we cannot tell who has offended whom.

The sonnet's shape follows the plot closely. The octave is two quatrains on just two rhymes, and the heavy *-ate* chime of "late", "state", "hate" and "sate" gives the quarrel a stuck, sulky feeling. The *b* rhyme should run through "love" and "prove" and "shove", so the pattern calls for a word chiming with them in line three. "More" is what this copy prints, and "move" would fit the sense, so it looks like a slip. The line "Brake bow, brake shafts, while Cupid weeping sate" is made of clipped, repeated syllables, and you can almost hear things snapping. Then the sestet turns on "Till that", bringing rescue and a change of mood. The verbs shift from past to present: Cupid "leaps", "crows", "falls". The rhymes lighten to "bows" and "crows", "play" and "way", and the two "Oh how" exclamations sound like a child squealing.

The rescuer is Cupid's "grandame Nature", and her gift is the compliment at the poem's centre. She makes him "two better bows" from Stella's brows, with "arrows infinite" in her eyes. Curved eyebrows really do look like bows, and bright eyes are an old comparison for love's darts, but Sidney gives the cliché a twist. Stella is Nature's own workmanship, so her face outclasses anything a goddess could make, and her supply of weapons never runs out. Nobody could have praised her more extravagantly, and the praise is hidden inside a joke about a toddler's tantrum.

The turn comes in the final couplet. Restored to power, Cupid behaves like "wags new got to play", mischievous boys with a fresh toy, and "Falls to shrewd turns". The word "shrewd" suggests cleverness but also a sting. Up to now the speaker has been invisible, a narrator telling a myth. Then he appears at the very end in four plain words: "and I was in his way". The grand classical machinery, with its gods, broken weapons and divine grandmother, comes down to a man standing where a child is firing. The tone is rueful and understated, even a little proud, since being hit by arrows made from Stella is its own kind of tribute.

That mix is what makes the poem worth reading. It uses the standard love-sonnet idea that a beautiful woman wounds her admirer, but it refuses to be solemn about it. The lover is not a noble sufferer but collateral damage, an accident nobody planned, and he knows how funny that looks. Sidney manages this in fourteen lines by keeping the myth lively and the rhymes tight, and by saving the speaker's own part for the last moment, when the joke finally lands on him.

Read also

More by Sir Philip Sidney

All poems
RomanticSir Philip Sidney

Come Sleep, O Sleep! The Certain Knot Of Peace

Come, Sleep! O Sleep, the certain knot of peace, The baiting-place of wit, the balm of woe, The poor man's wealth, the prisoner's release, Th' indifferent judge between the high and low;
RomanticSir Philip Sidney

Song from Arcadia

My true love hath my heart, and I have his, By Just Exchange, one for the other given. I hold his dear, and mine he cannot miss, There never was a better bargain driven.
ContemplativeSir Philip Sidney

Sonnet XVI: In Nature Apt

In nature apt to like when I did see Beauties, which were of many carats fine, My boiling sprites did thither soon incline, And, Love, I thought that I was full of thee: