February 27, 2015 — Poem analysis

AllyBelleContemplative

And you look through all these photos Spread out Showing all the things you've been through in life Capturing that still moment of what you care about to never forget it

And they can mean one of two things: How much you've lost Or how much you've grown

Life is all about perspective

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The poem begins with the word "And," as though we have walked in on someone halfway through a thought. That small choice sets the tone: a quiet, conversational voice talks to "you" about sitting down with old photographs. The scene is one anyone could recognise. The claim underneath is bolder for such a short piece: the same pile of pictures can tell two opposite stories, and which one you hear depends on you.

The first stanza widens as it goes. "Spread out" is a fragment on a line of its own, and it works almost like a stage direction. The words are short, so the reader can picture photos scattered across a floor or table. Then the lines stretch. "Showing all the things you've been through in life" is long and slightly shapeless, which suits its subject: a whole life crowded into one phrase. There is a neat echo here too. You "look through" the photos, and the photos show what you have "been through." One small word links looking back with living, as if browsing the past were another way of passing through it again.

The last line of the stanza holds the richest word in the poem: "still." A still moment is a motionless one, which is exactly what a photograph freezes. But "still" can also mean "continuing," and the moments here are ones the speaker still cares about. There is a gentle irony as well. The reason for taking a photo is "to never forget it," yet the poem goes straight on to show that a photo does not decide what the memory will mean. It keeps the moment, but not the feeling you will have about it later.

The turn comes after a blank line. The colon in "they can mean one of two things:" acts as a hinge, and what swings open is a pair of lines in deliberate parallel: "How much you've lost / Or how much you've grown." Both begin with "how much," which makes memory sound like arithmetic, a ledger where you add up what has gone and what has been gained. Both use the present perfect, a tense that reaches from the past into now, so neither loss nor growth is finished. The order matters too. The list ends on "grown," arguably the more hopeful word, and the ear tends to keep whatever it hears last. The poem offers an "or," but anyone who has grown after losing something might suspect the two are closer than that.

Then comes the line that stands alone: "Life is all about perspective." It is the only line that leaves "you" behind and speaks in a general voice. It is also the kind of sentence that could easily be dismissed as a poster slogan. In this poem, though, it has been earned, because a photograph is literally a perspective: a frame, a chosen angle, one moment cut out of everything around it. Deciding how to read the frame is the poem's whole argument. Its plainness is a kind of confidence. There is no ornate metaphor, no rhyme and no regular metre. It is free verse in everyday speech, and the line breaks do the work rhythm would otherwise do, slowing the reader at "Spread out" and letting the final line land in silence.

About the writer we have only what the page gives us: the name AllyBelle and the date February 27, 2015. The poem offers nothing more, and that may suit it, since the "you" stays open for any reader to step into. The poem's significance lies in that openness and in its refusal to pick a side. It does not tell us whether old photographs should make us sad or proud. It hands that choice back to us. For a student reader, it shows how a short poem can work with very little: a few ordinary words, one carefully placed hinge, and a last line that makes us look again at everything before it.

Read also

More by AllyBelle

All poems
RomanticAllyBelle

August 10th, 2015

Your eyes were the sea And just like the sea They swallowed me They were beautiful in ways that people wouldn't understand
ContemplativeAllyBelle

January 25th, 2016

I guess our problems in life are a little like rainstorms: You start with a drizzle Which doesn't seem too bad And is bearable
AngryAllyBelle

January 2nd, 2016

And I thought it'd be hell to live without you Now it'd hell to live with you And I can't stand to hear your name When did we come to this?