August 29th, 2015 — Poem analysis

She smiled and laughed to numb her pain But just like all medicine It wore off eventually

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A smile is normally read as proof that someone is fine. AllyBelle's three-line poem, dated August 29th, 2015, turns that assumption inside out. Here the smile and the laughter are a treatment for unhappiness, not a sign of its absence. "She smiled and laughed to numb her pain" gives us the whole situation in one breath, and the next two lines deliver the bad news that follows.

The central idea is that cheerfulness used as a painkiller brings relief but not a cure. The poem never says what hurts. We are shown the remedy and never the wound, which keeps the focus on the way of coping rather than on one particular sorrow. The word "numb" matters here. It belongs to the language of anaesthetic, and it describes something that removes feeling without removing the cause. Laughter in this poem doesn't heal anything. It only mutes it.

The pairing of "smiled and laughed" is also telling. One is a look and the other a sound, so both are things other people can see and hear. Pain, by contrast, is private. The line quietly sets an outward performance against an inner state, and the "She" of the poem is described from outside, as if by someone who can see through the performance. We aren't told whether "She" is the poet or someone she observed, and it's best not to assume. The ambiguity lets any reader step into the pronoun.

The hinge of the poem is the small word "But" at the start of line two. After it comes the simile "just like all medicine," and "all" does more work than it seems to. It turns a single sad case into a rule: laughter is placed among pills and doses, things taken for a limited time with a limited effect. If laughter is medicine, the image suggests, it has to be taken again and again, though the poem leaves that implication unspoken.

The phrase "wore off" works in two ways. For a drug, it means fading. But we also *wear* clothes, and a smile can be worn like a mask or an outfit. The image of a cheerful face worn thin, and a protective layer slipping away, sits comfortably inside a verb that seems at first to be about chemistry alone.

The sound and rhythm support this. The first line is almost perfectly regular, eight syllables falling into steady beats: "she SMILED and LAUGHED to NUMB her PAIN." That evenness feels like a performance held in place. Line two is shorter and slightly uneven, since "medicine" can be said with two or three syllables, so the rhythm stumbles just as the comparison arrives. The last line is the longest, and it ends on the five-syllable "eventually," whose final unstressed "-ly" lets the voice trail away. The poem fades as it describes fading. "Eventually" also carries a sense of time. The relief lasts a while, then ends, with no drama, which makes the line quietly cruel.

There is no rhyme. "Pain," "medicine" and "eventually" never chime, so the poem never gets the satisfying click that rhyme gives. In the text as supplied, it doesn't even end with a full stop. The soft, nasal sounds in "numb," "pain" and "medicine" give the words a muffled quality, which fits the subject, though that is an impression rather than a certainty. Everything is in the past tense as well: she smiled, it wore off. The story is already over, and the poem reports it flatly, without exclamation or self-pity.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it holds in so little space. It doesn't condemn laughter as dishonest, and it doesn't offer a solution. It simply notes a limit: a coping method can be real and still temporary. A single controlled metaphor carries the whole idea, which is a useful lesson in economy for any young writer. The poem also leaves a gap after its last word, where the reader has to ask what happens once the medicine has worn off and the feeling returns. By leaving that question open, it ends up saying more than three lines would seem to allow.

Read also

More by AllyBelle

All poems
ContemplativeAllyBelle

February 27, 2015

And you look through all these photos Spread out Showing all the things you've been through in life Capturing that still moment of what you care about to never forget it
SadAllyBelle

January 10th, 2016

"You must have really loved him." I looked down, Realizing what I have up, And what I had to do
AngryAllyBelle

January 2nd, 2016

And I thought it'd be hell to live without you Now it'd hell to live with you And I can't stand to hear your name When did we come to this?