Saving a Tree — Summary

Smiling in his Stihl chainsaw hat, had the arborist saved the tree from itself or from me? Had he saved my house or my neighbors’ from the heavy limbs? Maybe nothing

was ever going to fall, he told me gently as I wrote the check and we looked up admiringly at his work. When he left, I called to tell you how I knew

I was the tree that fell in the forest and nobody heard it. So did it make a sound? You said, Mandy, it made a sound, and you heard it, so tell me all about it. I told you,

I love you and I will.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

On the surface, a woman pays an arborist to trim or remove a tree and wonders whether the job was really needed. He tells her, kindly, that maybe nothing was ever going to fall. That small doubt opens something bigger. The speaker phones someone close to her and admits she feels like the tree that fell in the forest with nobody around to hear it.

The old riddle is about whether a sound exists without a listener. Here it becomes a question about loneliness: does her pain count if no one witnesses it? The reply is warm and simple. It made a sound, and you heard it, so tell me about it.

The mood begins wry and a little rueful, with the odd detail of the smiling chainsaw hat and the unanswered question of who was being saved. It softens into relief and tenderness. The last line, "I love you and I will," feels plain and sincere, as if she has finally been allowed to speak.

Read also

More by Amanda Laughtland

All poems
DreamyAmanda Laughtland

By the Puget Sound / By the Salish Sea

It might take fifty years for the waves to turn clear glass cloudy white, unmistakable as platinum blond hair in photos from 1936 when Grandma Dagmar