«hold me…» — Poem analysis

hold me not these tools a shape is worked into and above all say you know it's just too damned beauti- -ful.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Fourteen lines, none longer than two words, and almost no punctuation until the final full stop. Fourteen is the length of a sonnet, though it would be rash to call that deliberate, since nothing else here nods to the form: there is no rhyme and no regular meter. What replaces them is hesitation. Each line break makes the reader pause, so the poem feels less like a statement than like someone searching for the next thing to say.

The opening is built to be misread in two ways. "hold me / not / these tools" can be a plea: hold me, not these tools. But "hold me not" also sounds like the old-fashioned command "do not hold me," and the lone word "not" sits on its own line, free to point backward or forward. The line break lets both meanings stand. Whichever the speaker intends, the contrast is between being held by someone and being handled by instruments. The tools are then described in an odd, circling way: "a shape / is / worked into." The passive voice hides who is doing the working. Something is being formed, perhaps the speaker, perhaps the poem itself, but no hand is named. Even "is" gets a line of its own, so the verb of being hangs there, bare and slightly uneasy. Judging by the vocabulary of tools and shapes, the poem may be partly about craft, and about how the techniques that make something can get between people. That is a reading, not a certainty.

The single word "and" marks the turn. Up to this point the language is abstract and impersonal: tools, a shape, a passive construction. After it, the voice becomes intimate and direct. "above all / say / you know / it's just / too damned" is how people talk when they are trying to sound casual about something that matters. "You know" works twice. In "say you know," the speaker asks to hear that the other person understands. As a spoken filler, it is the verbal shrug of someone who cannot quite find the words. "just" does similar work, a small word that tries to make a large feeling sound offhand. The phrase "above all" tells us what the speaker wants most, and it is not an action but a few words spoken aloud. Being held matters, but being told matters more.

The poem then breaks its own key word in two: "beauti- / -ful." The hyphen appears at the end of one line and again at the start of the next, as though the word were stitched across a gap. Reading it aloud, you have to stumble, and the stumble is the point. The speaker is choking on the very thing they are praising. The suffix helps too, since "-ful" means "full of," and the fragment that finally arrives looks like fullness spilling over, which fits "too damned." That "damned" is the roughest word in the poem, and it turns the compliment into something closer to a complaint. Beauty here is not comfortable. It is excessive, almost an injury. The closing full stop is the only real punctuation in the poem, and it lands with a click after all that unpunctuated drift.

One more detail deserves attention: "it's" never has an antecedent. We are never told what is too beautiful, whether a person, a body, a moment, or a made thing. That gap keeps the poem open. Whatever "it" is, the speaker's reaction is the real subject, and because we are not told more, we fill the space with our own versions.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it does with so little. Line breaks produce two grammars at once. The plain speech of the second half cuts against the passive, impersonal first half. A single word is made to show the emotion it names by failing to come out whole. The central idea is a wish to be met with feeling rather than technique, together with the admission that feeling can overwhelm language. The poem makes its point by letting its own language falter.

Read also

More by Christine La Belle

All poems
DreamyChristine La Belle

* * *

you will come today tomorrow I hold a wet finger to the wind
ContemplativeChristine La Belle

* * *

The tree said stay. I stayed. The tree said
ContemplativeChristine La Belle

* * *

After sunset I wonder what color the birds' heads are