It Hurts — Poem analysis

Loving you and knowing, you won’t, hurts Crying deep within, but a broad smile on the face, hurts Not being a part of the special day, hurts Wishing for your happiness, at the cost of my tears, hurts

Looking into the wall to find you with the others, hurts More than a decade, but breaking heart in 10 seconds, hurts Realization of not being a part of your life, hurts Not able to share the feelings, hurts

You being like others, who left, hurts You not choosing me, hurts Moreover, it hurts that these things are not even half of what the mind feels!

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Eleven lines, and the same verb sits in every one of them. Ashmita Chatterjee's "It Hurts" is about unreturned love, but it is also about how little that experience can be put into words. The speaker loves someone who does not love back, and rather than telling a story or building a metaphor, she simply lists the moments where the ache shows up. The central idea is stated in the last line: all of this is "not even half of what the mind feels." The poem presents itself as an incomplete account.

The structure is the most obvious thing about it. Ten of the eleven lines end on "hurts," a repetition that works like a rhyme, although it is the same word every time rather than a matching sound. Each line follows the same pattern: a situation, a comma, then the verb. That comma matters. It makes the reader stop before "hurts," as if the speaker has to gather herself before admitting the pain again. The effect is closer to a wince than a sentence. The poem has no regular meter and no conventional rhyme scheme, and the lines vary in length, so the refrain provides the only pulse.

The plainness of "hurts" is a choice. The speaker never compares her feelings to a wound, a storm or a fire. She uses the smallest word available, and the details do the rest. "Crying deep within, but a broad smile on the face" gives two images, one hidden and one visible, and the gap between them is the loneliness of the poem. "Wishing for your happiness, at the cost of my tears" compresses the same idea into a trade: her generosity costs her something, and she pays it quietly. Even the opening line leaves a gap. "Loving you and knowing, you won't" never says what the other person won't do, and the missing word makes the rejection feel too obvious, or too painful, to spell out.

The second stanza turns to specific scenes, though the poem still keeps back as much as it shows. "Looking into the wall to find you with the others" could be a wall of photographs or, judging by the phrasing, a feed of other people's moments. Either way, she is looking at a place she is not part of. The line "More than a decade, but breaking heart in 10 seconds" sets two measures of time against each other. Years of feeling are undone in a moment, and the plain numerals make that moment sound brisk and almost clinical. The word "special day" in the first stanza has the same effect: we never learn what the occasion was, only that she was left out of it.

The pronouns shift across the poem. The first stanza stays mostly with the speaker's own body and feelings: tears, a smile, a wish. In the third stanza the other person becomes the subject of the sentences: "You being like others, who left," and "You not choosing me." The speaker's private sorrow ends in two accusations, though they are mild ones. The first is the more painful. She had hoped this person was different, and being "like others" is a second loss on top of the first. The second is the barest statement of what happened.

The ending breaks the pattern. The last line is longer, opens with "Moreover," and ends with an exclamation mark, and "it hurts" moves from the end of the line to the middle. It is the one place where the poem loses its composure, and it does so by admitting that the list has failed. Notice also that the word is "mind," not "heart." The pain here is not only a single heartbreak but also the constant replaying of scenes, which is what the poem has just been doing.

What makes the poem worth reading is that it enacts its own problem. One line says, "Not able to share the feelings, hurts," and yet the poem is the act of sharing them. The repetition can look limited at first, but it is the right form for a feeling that circles back to the same point however many times you try to move on. For students, it is a good example of how simplicity can carry weight: a short word, repeated, with careful pauses and one broken pattern, is enough to make a reader feel the insistence of the hurt.

Read also