Everyone’s Worst Critic — Summary

I don’t appreciate that language, Don’t appreciate that tone, As I utter numerous profanities, As I scream and yell, You must be more loyal, Must be more honest, As I exit the hotel with my mistress, Having told my wife I was out of town, You shouldn’t smoke or drink, Addiction is for the weak, Smoking my second pack of the day, Two weeks removed from AA, Gossip shows a lack of maturity, It shows a lack of respect, Did you hear about what’s his name? How can he live with himself? Constantly critical of others, With no hesitation present, Holding back no remorse, Being just as guilty as the rest of them.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Hypocrisy is the whole point here. The speaker lectures others about language, loyalty, honesty, addiction and gossip, then immediately shows how badly he fails at each one. The lines of judgment alternate with lines of confession: he scolds about tone while screaming profanities, demands honesty while sneaking out of a hotel with his mistress, and condemns drinking and smoking while on his second pack of the day, just two weeks out of AA.

The speaker seems to feel righteous and self-assured, though the poem clearly wants us to see through him. There's no sign he notices the contradiction. Even the gossip, "Did you hear about what's his name?", comes from the same mouth that condemns gossip.

The mood is sharp and darkly ironic, with a hint of discomfort. The final lines turn the accusation on him directly: he is "just as guilty as the rest of them." The title lands as a joke, and perhaps a warning, since the harshest critic often has the most to hide.

Read also

More by Craig Rozniecki

All poems
RomanticCraig Rozniecki

Better Than Sex

To look into your eyes, Feel your hand in mine, To see you laugh, See you smile,
AngryCraig Rozniecki

Middle School

As of the first day, Cliques are formed, The bullies and jocks, Geeks and band nerds,
SadCraig Rozniecki

Self-Reflection

Is it my face? Does she cringe when I’m near? Is it my voice? A sound she can’t stand to hear?