Dating game — Poem analysis

Dave BontaCheerful

a mouth on you like a clock at a bad dinner

tell me pretty stories about arson

preach to me a sermon on holy war

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Six short lines are enough to turn a date into a standoff between boredom and appetite. Dave Bonta's "Dating game" never tells us who is speaking, where they are, or whether the evening ends well. We get a voice, a simile, and two commands, and from those we have to work out the mood. The central idea seems to be that courtship runs on talk, and that when talk goes dead, the mind reaches for the most violent material it can find. The speaker would rather hear about fire and holy war than sit through one more polite silence.

The first couplet sets the trap. "A mouth on you" is a slippery phrase. In casual speech it can be a complaint about someone's sharp or ceaseless tongue, but it can also point at the mouth as a body part, something to kiss or be kissed by. The poem lets both meanings hang there. Then comes the comparison: the mouth is "like a clock at a bad dinner." Anyone who has sat through an awkward meal knows the clock. It is the one thing you keep looking at, and its ticking becomes the loudest sound in the room. The image suggests a mouth that measures time instead of filling it, one that is watched, counted, and resented. It might also be a mouth that keeps interrupting, like a chiming hour. The simile is funny and a little cruel, and it tells us the speaker is already half out the door.

The second and third couplets turn to imperatives: "tell me pretty stories / about arson," then "preach to me a sermon / on holy war." The speaker stops complaining and starts placing an order. The requests escalate neatly, from private destruction to public destruction. Arson is one person with a match. Holy war is whole armies acting under a banner of righteousness. The forms of speech escalate too, from "stories," which are intimate and meant for a bedside or a table, to a "sermon," which is delivered from a height to a crowd. The speaker wants a performance, and the date has to supply it.

The word "pretty" is the hinge of the poem. Nothing about arson is pretty, and that is exactly why the word stings. It shows a taste for beauty that has come loose from conscience, where flames are admired the way you might admire a sunset. "Holy" works the same way. It dresses up violence in sacred language, and the phrase "holy war" is itself a small act of that dressing-up. The speaker asks to be soothed with destruction, and the poem leaves us unsure whether this is flirtation, sarcasm, or a real hunger for intensity. Tone is the open question here. These could be the words of someone deliberately provoking a date, or of someone so numbed by the clock that only catastrophe can wake them.

The construction is spare. There is no rhyme and no punctuation, and everything is lowercase, so the lines sound like speech tossed across a table instead of a finished statement. Each couplet follows the same shape, a longer first line and a shorter second, and the short lines carry the weight: "arson" and "holy war" each get a line break to themselves, so the dangerous words arrive last and land hard. Some sound-play ties the poem together. "Pretty" and "preach" share their opening consonant, which links beauty to sermonizing, and the sounds in "arson" and "sermon" nearly echo each other, as if the two requests were variations on one appetite.

The title adds a final twist. Calling a date a "game" suggests rules, moves, and a scoreboard, which makes the whole encounter feel staged. If dating is a game, then the speaker's demands are a kind of move, a challenge to see whether the other player can do something more than keep the dinner polite.

The poem's significance lies in this compression. In about twenty words it captures how ordinary social ritual can feel suffocating, and how that feeling can make dangerous things seem attractive. It also makes us a little uneasy about our own appetite for stories of burning and war, and about how easily we ask for them to be told prettily. Because the poem stops without an answer, the reader is left sitting at the table too, listening for what the mouth will say next.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss