Note To You — Poem analysis

It has been quite the while Has it not? Since I've written for you and to you Though I still feel like I've been shot What do I say? Do I have the right to talk? Would I even be able to? To say what I want and walk the walk Because I feel guilty I feel regret and sorrow I feel like it's just another now And just another tomorrow I want to say I'm sorry But how do I? When you are no longer here When I never said goodbye

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Dominic Black's "Note To You" begins like a message dashed off to an old friend: "It has been quite the while / Has it not?" The tag question is breezy, even polite, the kind of thing you say to someone you expect to answer. The poem spends its sixteen lines taking that expectation apart. By the last stanza we learn the listener is "no longer here," and the casual opening starts to look like a rehearsal, a speaker talking to someone as though nothing had changed.

The poem is about guilt and the difficulty of apologising when it is too late. It never says who "you" is, how they were lost, or what the speaker did or failed to do, so it is safest to stay with what the words allow. The speaker once wrote "for you and to you," which suggests a bond carried partly through writing, and has since fallen silent. Whether "no longer here" means death or some other final parting is left open, but "I never said goodbye" points to an ending that came without a proper farewell. The central idea is that the urge to say sorry outlives the person who should hear it.

The form is plain. There are four quatrains, and in each the second and fourth lines rhyme: not/shot, talk/walk, sorrow/tomorrow, I/goodbye. It is a ballad-like pattern, simple and almost songlike, which suits something called a "note" rather than an elegy. The rhythm is loose and close to speech, with lines of uneven length. The very short ones, "Has it not?", "What do I say?" and "But how do I?", work like stumbles or held breaths. There are five questions in all and not one answer. "Would I even be able to?" even trails off on a dangling "to," as though the speaker loses his nerve before the sentence can finish.

Imagery is rationed. The poem's only real picture is "I've been shot," and it lands hard in a voice that is otherwise quiet and hesitant. The tense matters: the speaker doesn't say he was shot but that he "still feel[s] like I've been shot," so the wound is not healing. A gunshot is also something you don't see coming, which fits the shock of a goodbye that never happened. The third stanza then turns flat. "I feel" is repeated three times, each time followed by a plain naming of the emotion: guilty, regret, sorrow. The speaker lists his feelings rather than explaining them, as if that is all he can manage. "Just another now / And just another tomorrow" stretches that flatness across time. Nothing separates today from the future, and grief has become a loop.

Some word choices strain against the rhyme, and that is revealing too. "To say what I want and walk the walk" leans on a well-worn idiom about backing up words with action. The line may be pulled partly by the need to rhyme with "talk," but it also exposes the speaker's helplessness, since action is exactly what is no longer possible. All he has left is words, and he doubts he has "the right" even to those.

The final stanza is the cleverest. "I want to say I'm sorry" is as close as the poem comes to an apology, and it is hedged by the wanting. The word "sorry" also echoes "sorrow" from the stanza before, as though regret and grief were the same thing in different clothes. Then comes the closing rhyme, which links "how do I?" to "goodbye." The speaker's own "I" is bound to the farewell he never gave. The poem's very last word is "goodbye," so it ends by naming the thing it lacked, even while saying it was never said.

That is where the poem's strength lies. It doesn't resolve, console, or decorate its pain. Everyday diction, a steady rhyme scheme and a run of unanswered questions give a believable picture of a mind circling something it can't fix. The note exists, and it addresses someone who can't read it. The poem suggests that writing the words anyway is all that remains.

Read also

More by Dominic Black

All poems
SadDominic Black

Why?

Every time I look into your eyes I see a kind, broken heart I see a shadow of the person you used to be before the world turned dark
RomanticDominic Black

I Remember

I studied your face Fell in love With your perfections That you call flaws
SadDominic Black

Another Sad Story

I lost a friend who could have been more if distance wasn't so long if she hadn't gotten so sore