«I stare up at the sky and…» — Poem analysis

frėėdömwrïtėrContemplative

I stare up at the sky and I wonder if the snow gets tired of falling Or if the rain is eager to run dry

At night I wonder if the stars get tired of shinning bright And if they're like people Holding onto broken thread Struggling to hang on But desperately wanting to fall

I wonder if the birds simply don't want to fly And want to stay home Somber and solemn Till they get sick of being in their nests

I wonder if the sun struggles to rise And is desperate to set Or if the moon ever wishes to not been seen

I wonder if the leaves find it hard when autumn comes And if it hurts to let go From the branches up above

I wonder if the clouds ever desire to fade To be whisked away Hidden from the day

I wonder if the waters just want to disperse If the waves ever get bored of the splish and the splash If they ever just want to take a break From being a home to the animals of the sea

I wonder if the grass gets angry after being trampled and eaten It grows and is trampled It restores itself Then it's eaten Just to regrow again every season

I wonder if the trees think its worth it To live and to die To come back to life To be desecrated by dogs and drunks To be cut down To be stripped To be abused Just to die And be forced to regrow every spring Just to be treated the same way all over again

I wonder if fire ever gets sick of burning And desires to switch places with water And if water ever desires to switch places with fire

I wonder if the air desires to pause Desires to take a mental health day And clean itself of all the filth People put into it

I wonder if the earth ever tires of rotating If it's axis gets rusty as it turn and turns

I wonder If the nature of things Ever desires not to function as created to The way people do

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

We usually describe nature as calm, dependable, even soothing. The speaker of this untitled poem, which has only a row of asterisks where a title would be, stares at the sky and asks a stranger question: what if everything out there is exhausted? Snow might be tired of falling, the sun might struggle to rise, and the earth's axis might be going rusty. The questions pile up until it becomes clear that the speaker is really describing a weariness closer to home.

The poem's structure is simple and deliberate. Nearly every stanza begins "I wonder if," and the repetition works like a person lying awake at night, letting one thought lead to the next. There is no rhyme and no regular rhythm. The lines are as long as a thought needs, which gives the poem the feel of speech rather than song. Sound still creeps in where it matters. "Somber and solemn" and "the splish and the splash" are playful, almost childlike, and they sit oddly beside the fatigue they describe. The bored waves are funny until you notice they are being asked to be "a home to the animals of the sea" forever, without a break.

The images are strongest where they are most specific. The stars are compared to "people / Holding onto broken thread / Struggling to hang on / But desperately wanting to fall." That is a striking picture of being stuck between endurance and release, and it is the poem's most emotionally loaded moment. Other stanzas carry the same longing for rest, in verbs like "disperse," "fade," "pause" and "set." Mostly the wish is for a break rather than an ending, though the stars' wish to fall edges towards something heavier. The air that wants "a mental health day" is a witty touch. It drags a modern, workplace phrase into a poem about the cosmos, and the joke lands because the feeling behind it is real.

The grass and trees show the poem's technique best. For the grass, the syntax copies the cycle: "It grows and is trampled / It restores itself / Then it's eaten." The sentences are short and flat, and they loop without any sense of reward. The tree stanza is the longest in the poem, and its list gets harsher as it goes: "desecrated by dogs and drunks," "cut down," "stripped," "abused." A word like "desecrated" belongs to sacred things, and "abused" belongs to people, so the language starts to treat the tree as a victim rather than a plant. The repeated "Just to" ("Just to die," "Just to treat the same way all over again") turns renewal into a burden. Spring, usually the season of hope, becomes something the tree is "forced" into. The air stanza adds blame, since the "filth / People put into it" names humans as the cause of some of this tiredness.

Then the poem changes. The last stanza isolates "I wonder" on its own line, as if the speaker has stopped circling and is finally about to say the real thing: "If the nature of things / Ever desires not to function as created to / The way people do." The phrase "the way people do" shows what the earlier questions were doing. The speaker has been lending nature a human reluctance to keep going, and in the end admits it. The ending can be read two ways. It may suggest that nature, like people, might want to refuse its role. It may also suggest that people are the ones who feel that refusal most sharply, while the sun keeps rising regardless. The poem leaves both possibilities open.

The writing has rough edges, such as "shinning," "it's axis" and "turn and turns." They do not damage the effect. They keep the voice sounding like a real person thinking aloud rather than a polished performance.

The poem is worth reading because it turns a familiar technique, giving human feelings to nature, into a way of admitting something personal. Because the speaker never says "I am tired," the confession is gentler and more believable. The poem also asks whether the things we think of as simply doing their job might be carrying a burden we have never thought to ask about.

Read also

More by frėėdömwrïtėr

All poems
Contemplativefrėėdömwrïtėr

* * *

beneath me there is ground and above me there is sky somedays im like the stars & i find a place among the clouds