«One day I said "please, hold my hands…» — Poem analysis

One day I said "please, hold my hands Promise don't forget me" I confessed my fears, my dreams, my love You said "Yes, of course I'll remember of us" You said "No problem, I feel the same to you" I believed in every word, every confession I had hopes From time to time you returned saying again "I love you so much, no doubt" And I dreamed I made plans for us You repeat again and again "I love you my baby, no doubt" Suddenly, you disappear No replied to my messages And I think "Oh no, he has a problem! What does he doing?!" I worried with your health Suddenly, you return And simply says "I don't love you like I said yesterday" In the end, you were never sure I and my fuckin ilusions

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Love poems usually trade in feeling. This one trades in sentences: who said what, and how many times. It opens with a request, "please, hold my hands / Promise don't forget me," that is physical and a little childlike. The speaker follows it with a confession of "my fears, my dreams, my love," a list that moves from the most vulnerable things to the largest. The answer sounds generous until you listen to its wording. "Yes, of course" and "No problem" are what we say when someone asks a small favour, like passing the salt. The speaker hears devotion, but a reader may hear ease.

The poem has no rhyme and no regular metre. It is free verse that reads like a story told to a friend, with the shape of speech rather than song. Line length does a lot of the work. His quoted promises sprawl, while the speaker's own responses shrink to a few words: "I had hopes." "And I dreamed." "I made plans for us." These short lines stack up like bricks. Believing, hoping, dreaming and planning are each given a line to themselves, so the reader watches a future being built one sentence at a time, and the second half of the poem takes it down.

Repetition is the poem's main tool, and it works against the promises it repeats. He returns "saying again" that he loves her, then "again and again," each time with the same "no doubt." The more often reassurance has to be offered, the less reassuring it becomes. By the time we reach "In the end, you were never sure," that phrase "no doubt" has turned into bitter irony.

The word "Suddenly" appears twice, once for his disappearance and once for his return. Using the same word for both makes his comings and goings feel like weather, arriving without warning or explanation. In the silence between them, the speaker's thoughts break into the poem as the only exclamation marks: "Oh no, he has a problem! What does he doing?!" She is hunting for an excuse on his behalf. "I worried with your health" goes further, because she invents an illness for him rather than consider indifference. The tenderness here is real, but it is also a form of self-deception.

The blow, when it comes, is flat: "I don't love you like I said yesterday." That one word, "yesterday," shrinks the whole affair. After "from time to time" and "again and again," the love is reduced to a statement a day old and already cancelled. "Simply says" matches the easy tone of "No problem" earlier, so the cruelty and the kindness come out of the same casual voice.

The English is also uneven in places ("No replied," "I worried with your health," "ilusions"), and the tense slides between past and present, as in "You repeat" and "simply says." Judging by the text alone, these slips give the poem the rawness of a message typed in a hurry. The present-tense verbs also make the pattern of vanishing and returning feel unfinished, as if it could happen again tomorrow.

The final line sits apart from the rest: "I and my fuckin ilusions." It is the only profanity, and its target is the speaker herself, not him. The grammar matters too. "I and my" pairs the speaker with her illusions in the way "us" once paired her with him. The couple she planned has been replaced by a partnership of one person and her own hopes. The anger turns inward, from "you lied" to "I believed," and that is harder to bear than blame.

The poem's significance lies in its honesty rather than polish. It shows how the same words can cost one person nothing and another person everything. It also shows that plain language, short lines and well-placed repetition can carry a whole emotional arc without ornament. The clumsiness of the English becomes part of the voice, and the voice is what makes the ending sting.

Read also

More by Gabrielle Andreza

All poems
SadGabrielle Andreza

* * *

In the school students reading. In the street people walking. In the church people praying. In my bed I cry and my heart broken.
SadGabrielle Andreza

* * *

I am made for you You are don't made for me I hope without hopeness Without certain
RomanticGabrielle Andreza

* * *

I would like you to kiss me If you were loved me If you were stay with me and you were hug me If you were touch me