May 14, 2011 — Poem analysis

meowSad

When he left I didn't cry. Even though I loved him, I never shed a tear. I might later but for now I'm in a state of shock, I feel an ache in my heart but I still don't have any tears. My eyes are getting blurry, the page is getting wet. Oh, hello tears. I'm surprised we met.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Most poems about heartbreak begin with tears. This one begins by refusing them. "When he left I didn't cry," the speaker announces, and for the first half of the poem she keeps insisting on it, almost like someone defending herself in court. Then her body overrules her mid-sentence. The poem is about the gap between how we expect grief to look and how it actually arrives, and its central idea is that feeling can't be scheduled or argued with, even by the person feeling it.

The opening lines are flat and declarative, and they lean on negatives: "didn't cry," "never shed a tear," "still don't have any tears." Three times in five lines the speaker says the same thing, and the repetition gives her away. Someone who is truly calm doesn't need to keep saying so. The phrase "Even though I loved him" is just as revealing. It treats crying as proof of love, as if the lack of tears needs an excuse. The speaker seems to feel she owes the reader, or herself, an explanation for her dry eyes.

The fourth line is the longest and most breathless: "I might later but for now I'm in a state of shock." It has no pause, and it reaches for a ready-made phrase, "state of shock," the way people do when they can't find words of their own. The next line sets the poem's central contrast, an "ache in my heart" against the absence of tears. The ache is inside her and invisible, while tears would be outside and visible. The poem is built on that opposition between dry and wet, hidden and shown.

The turn comes quietly, in the grammar. Until now the speaker has used simple past and present tenses to state facts. Then the verbs change to "getting": "My eyes are getting blurry, / the page is getting wet." The continuous tense makes the poem happen in real time, with no gap between the feeling and the line that records it. The detail of the *page* getting wet also tells us the speaker is writing as she cries. The poem isn't remembered afterward. It is being written at the moment her denial breaks, and the paper absorbs what her words had been holding back. The blurring matters too. Her sight goes at the very moment her self-description turns out to be wrong.

The ending is the poem's best stroke: "Oh, hello tears. / I'm surprised we met." Here the speaker personifies her tears, greeting them like an acquaintance she bumps into on the street. The politeness is almost comic, and it works as a shield, a small joke to cover a moment that is anything but small. "Oh" captures the surprise of someone noticing something she didn't expect. "Met" is a curious choice, since tears are about as intimate as a companion can be, yet she treats them as strangers. That suggests how far she had kept herself from her own feelings.

The poem is mostly unrhymed, which suits its plain, speech-like voice and its loose, uneven lines. That makes the one clear rhyme at the end, "wet" and "met," more noticeable. After a stretch of unshaped statements, the rhyme clicks shut like a small realization. The final couplet also shortens the lines, so the poem seems to run out of breath just as the tears arrive.

The poem gives no details about who "he" is or how he left. The word could mean a breakup or something more final, and the text doesn't settle it. That vagueness helps the poem, because it keeps the focus on the speaker's reaction, not on a story. The date given with the poem, May 14, 2011, and the name credited, meow, are all the context we have, so the poem has to stand on what is written.

What makes it worth reading is its honesty about being surprised by yourself. It doesn't announce that grief is overwhelming. It shows someone catching her own feelings in the act, and it handles that moment with understatement and a dry little joke that doesn't quite hold.

Read also

More by meow

All poems
Sadmeow

September 14th, 2015

So many faces, So many frowns, It's always this day that turns my world upside-down, Where is the joy?
Sadmeow

I'm sorry

I'm sorry about who I am I'm sorry I exist I'm sorry I'm a stupid bitch I'm sorry I'm a piece of shit
Sadmeow

March 23th, 2011

Why bother talking to me? You know you'll never listen. Why bother complimenting me? You won't accomplish anything.