Love, a Lost Cause? — Poem analysis

MaryllisesContemplative

I sit and wonder Wonder if love was forced What if love was not real I love music May my life be devoted to music For my music loves me back I watch couples kiss and dance A few weeks later Watching them wanting to kill each other Maybe love isn't something you should think about Maybe, just maybe It should be lost Never to be touched or seen again

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A speaker sits alone with a question most people ask quietly and few put on paper: what if love isn't real? The title, "Love, a Lost Cause?", poses it, and the poem is a short, restless attempt at an answer. Its central idea is that romantic love is unreliable, perhaps even manufactured, while devotion to music is the one kind of love the speaker trusts, because it is returned. The surprise is where the poem ends. It doesn't mourn love as lost. It suggests love ought to be.

The opening shows a mind thinking in real time. "I sit and wonder / Wonder if love was forced" repeats its own last word, as if the thought snagged and had to be restarted. "Forced" is a loaded choice. It could mean love is imposed on people by expectation, or that it is faked and performed. The poem doesn't decide, and "What if love was not real" pushes the doubt further without even a question mark. In fact, the only punctuation in the body of the poem is a single comma, in "Maybe, just maybe", which falls exactly where the speaker hesitates before the most extreme idea. The unpunctuated lines read like unedited thought.

Then comes the turn: "I love music." It is the plainest declaration in the poem, and the next line lifts it into something like a vow. "May my life be devoted to music" borrows the language of prayer and wedding promises. The speaker gives music what couples are supposed to give each other. The reason follows: "For my music loves me back." The possessive "my" makes music a partner, and the small word "back" carries the argument. What the speaker finds missing in human love is reciprocity.

The evidence against romance comes in a miniature story. "I watch couples kiss and dance" puts the speaker outside the scene, a spectator, and kissing and dancing are public, almost staged. Then the hinge: "A few weeks later." Standing alone, the line skips an entire relationship in one flat breath, the way a cynic might. What follows, "Watching them wanting to kill each other", shifts from "watch" to "Watching", as though the observing never stops, and the repeated *w* sounds give the line a muttering, sour edge. "Kill each other" is exaggeration, but exaggeration is how disillusionment often speaks. Notice also the timescale: weeks, not years. In the speaker's sample, love barely outlasts the dance.

The ending is where the poem becomes most interesting. "Maybe love isn't something you should think about" suddenly addresses a general "you", and it is quietly self-contradicting, since the whole poem has been thinking about nothing else. The speaker advises stopping the very thing they cannot stop. Then the title's idiom is turned inside out. A "lost cause" is a hopeless effort, but here the speaker proposes that love "should be lost / Never to be touched or seen again." Love is treated like a dangerous object to be locked away. The senses named, touch and sight, are those of the kissing couples from earlier. Music, the speaker's own love, is never described that way. The question mark of the title also disappears by the end, though the hedging "Maybe" keeps the verdict from sounding fully settled.

Structurally, the poem is free verse with no rhyme and no regular meter. The lines are short and speech-like, and repetition does the work rhyme might have done: "wonder" and "Wonder", "Maybe" and "maybe", "love" and "loves", "watch" and "Watching". Line length follows feeling. Confessions like "I love music" are brief, while the irritation of "Watching them wanting to kill each other" and the reasoning of "Maybe love isn't something you should think about" stretch out.

What makes the poem worth reading is its honesty and its hidden contradiction. A speaker who says love may not be real also says "I love music" and "my music loves me back." So the poem is less an attack on love than a redefinition of it: love is whatever answers you, whatever stays. In very few words it moves from doubt, through a personal alternative and a piece of cynical evidence, to a stark conclusion, and it leaves us wondering whether the speaker has truly given up on love or only on the version they keep seeing on the dance floor.

Read also

More by Maryllises

All poems
ContemplativeMaryllises

The Gators

As i walk along the gators track I see hundreds of worms crawling Crawling along the rough gravely track Even though the stadiums empty
RomanticMaryllises

Dream Boy

Your eyes are green… Or maybe brown or blue But whatever color they are They remind me of spring.
RomanticMaryllises

Letting Go, Being Free

Here we are With one quest in life To be free How is this virtuous prize to be won