Unanswered Questions — Poem analysis

If I love you, can I trust you? If I see you, are you with me? If I hear you, are you talking? If I'm with you, would you leave me? If I tried to help you, would you let me? Feels so different, Feels so distant. I try to be there But I get pushed away.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Five questions, all beginning with "If", pile up before Olivia Taylor's speaker says anything she is sure of. "Unanswered Questions" is about caring for someone who is slipping out of reach. The speaker cannot tell whether the problem is the other person's silence or her own uncertainty, and the poem's central idea is that love without reassurance turns into a kind of interrogation. The speaker is not demanding answers so much as asking, over and over, for permission to stay close.

The structure is easy to see and hard to shake. Each of the first five lines repeats the same frame: "If I love you…", "If I see you…", "If I hear you…", "If I'm with you…", "If I tried to help you…". This repetition, called anaphora, gives the opening a rehearsed, circling quality, like someone who has run the same worries through her head many times. The "if" also hedges everything. Even the speaker's own love is phrased as a condition, "If I love you", as though she cannot state a feeling plainly while she doubts how it will be received.

The questions also move through a sequence of experiences: loving, seeing, hearing, being with, helping. Each one asks whether the connection is real. The pairs are slightly off-balance. "If I see you, are you with me?" separates looking at someone from actually being with them. "If I hear you, are you talking?" is stranger still. You might expect the speaker to ask whether she is being heard, but she asks whether the other person is really speaking to her. Judging by the wording, she hears something, perhaps noise or fragments, that does not feel like communication. Then "with you" in line four mirrors "with me" in line two, so the two people are placed side by side in the grammar even while the content suggests they are apart.

The verbs change as well. The early questions use the present tense ("are you with me?"), but by the end the phrasing is "would you leave me?" and "would you let me?" The speaker is moving from what is happening to what might happen. The last question, "If I tried to help you", slips into the past tense, and "tried" already sounds like an attempt that has failed. Line length follows this pattern. The first four lines run to roughly eight syllables each, giving a steady, anxious beat, while the fifth stretches out, as if the speaker is pushing to finish a request she half expects to be refused.

Then the poem drops sharply into short lines: "Feels so different, / Feels so distant." These two lines are the nearest thing to an answer, though they describe a feeling rather than a fact. The repeated "Feels so" and the matching sounds of "different" and "distant" make them seem to follow each other helplessly. There are no question marks left. After five questions the poem stops asking, which suggests the speaker has given up expecting replies.

The imagery is sparse. The poem mostly uses abstract words like "trust", "love" and "different", and the senses of sight and hearing appear only as verbs, never as pictures. That makes the final physical image land hard: "But I get pushed away." Until now, closeness and distance have been measured in words and feelings, and here the distance becomes a shove. The grammar matters too. The speaker begins the last two lines in control ("I try to be there") but ends in the passive ("I get pushed"). The "But" is the poem's only real turn, and it is the point where effort meets rejection.

There is almost no end rhyme, which suits the subject. The lines "with me", "leave me" and "let me" do echo one another, and the repeated "me" keeps pulling the speaker back to her own position as the one waiting and wondering. Nothing is resolved, which fits the title. The poem ends on "away", a direction rather than a conclusion.

What makes the poem worth reading is its plainness. It does not name the "you" as a friend, partner or family member, and the poem gives no reason for the distance, so readers can fill in their own situations. Its power comes from recognition, since many people have wanted to help someone who would not be helped and have replayed the conversation in their heads afterwards. By letting the questions pile up and then simply stop, the poem shows how that feeling works: not as a single dramatic break, but as a slow, uncertain drifting apart.

Read also

More by Olivia Taylor

All poems
AngryOlivia Taylor

I'm done

I see you've been home But again now you're gone You said you'd let me know In case I'd want to see you
SadOlivia Taylor

Players

I can tell it's over Way before it's over Love is not enough I really wish it was.
SadOlivia Taylor

I Was Wrong

I thought I was making a fool of myself Getting dressed so we could leave As soon as you came, But you never did.