Untitled 061 — Poem analysis

P N C L S C R P TContemplative

We are not friends. We aren't less. We aren't more. We're somewhere in between all of that.

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Three denials and a shrug: that is the whole architecture of "Untitled 061." The speaker never says what the relationship is. Instead we get a list of what it isn't ("We are not friends. / We aren't less. / We aren't more.") until the language gives out and the poem settles for a vague spot on the map: "somewhere in between all of that." The poem is about a bond with no name, and its central idea is that some connections live in the gap between the words we have for them.

The logic of the first three lines is more tricky than it looks. "We are not friends" sounds like a plain statement of distance. Then the speaker rules out "less," which closes off the idea that the two are strangers or mere acquaintances. Next comes "more," which shuts the door on anything grander. Friendship quietly becomes the midpoint of a ladder, and the speaker steps off it in both directions. What is left is a relationship that fits no rung, which is why the final line has to reach for a spatial word, "between," instead of a label.

The grammar tells its own small story. The first denial is spelled out in full, "are not," and it lands like a firm, deliberate statement. After that the speaker relaxes into contractions: "aren't," "aren't," and finally the affirmative "We're." The shift is subtle, but it moves the voice from a formal declaration to something more tired and offhand, as if the speaker has explained this before, perhaps even to themselves, and has given up on sounding certain.

The rhythm does the same work. The first three lines are clipped, running to about four, three and three syllables, and each ends with a full stop. They have the flat finality of a door being closed three times. Then the last line sprawls to roughly nine syllables, with no sharp stop until the very end. Where the short lines tried to pin things down, the long one drifts, and the poem's form acts out the problem it describes: the more the speaker tries to be exact, the less exactness is available. There is no rhyme to tidy things up, which suits a poem about something that refuses to resolve. The nearest thing to an echo is the faint sound-link between "friends" and "between," as if the word the speaker rejected is still lurking inside the one they settle on.

The key words are small, and each does careful work. "We" appears in every line. Even as the speaker denies one label after another, the pronoun keeps the two people grammatically joined, so the poem never admits that nothing exists between them. Only the name is missing. "Somewhere" is deliberately imprecise, a place you can't point to on a map. And "all of that" is the most interesting phrase in the poem. "That" is a pointing word with nothing specific to point at, so the categories of friendship, lesser and greater, get waved away in one dismissive gesture. It sounds casual, but it can also read as weary, or as protective, a way of not looking too closely at what the "in between" actually contains.

Two details outside the four lines invite some speculation, though only as inference. The title, "Untitled 061," suggests the piece belongs to a longer sequence, and the refusal to title it fits the poem's refusal to label the relationship. The byline is presented as spaced-out consonants, with the vowels stripped away, which is an unusual way to sign a poem about something unnamed. Beyond what appears on the page, I can't say anything reliable about the poet or the circumstances of writing, and the poem doesn't need that help.

What makes it significant is how much it manages in so little space. Many readers will recognise the feeling of a connection that doesn't fit the vocabulary of friend, partner or stranger, and the poem gives that feeling a shape without trying to fix it. It also suggests that "I don't know what to call this" can be an honest and complete answer. The poem ends without a verdict, in the open space the speaker has so patiently cleared by saying what the relationship is not.

Read also

More by P N C L S C R P T

All poems
SadP N C L S C R P T

Untitled 031

// All the love stories I wrote were just the introductions
RomanticP N C L S C R P T

Untitled 101

Taking things slowly hesitantly Don't want to hurt
RomanticP N C L S C R P T

Untitled 013

no. i don't love you to the moon and back