Moral Dilemmas 2 — Summary

Mike StoneContemplative

I can't kill you.

If I can't kill them, then who can I kill?

If it's wrong to kill, is it ever right to kill?

Where is the line drawn?

Between them and us?

Between humans and animals?

Between conscious animals and unconscious animals?

Between animals and plants?

Can I kill something that is not living?

Yes. It is called destruction.

If it's wrong to destroy, is it ever right to destroy?

Where is the line drawn?

Between a work of art and something useful?

Between something useful and something useless?

Your world or someone else's?

A distant star?

A grain of sand?

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Mike Stone's poem starts with a blunt, personal refusal: "I can't kill you." From there it turns into a chain of questions, each one growing out of the last. If the speaker can't kill one person, who can they kill? If killing is wrong, is it ever right? The poem keeps asking where the line sits, first between "them and us," then between humans and animals, animals and plants, and finally between living and non-living things.

The turning point is the short answer "Yes. It is called destruction." After that, the same logic is applied to destroying things, and the questions get wider and stranger: art versus usefulness, your world versus someone else's, a distant star, a grain of sand.

The speaker sounds unsettled rather than certain. The mood is quiet, stripped-down and a little unnerving, because every line drawn seems to wobble when pushed. The poem gives no answers, and that leaves the reader sitting with the discomfort.

Read also

More by Mike Stone

All poems
CheerfulMike Stone

Noellen

Noellen, I say and then stop because love is the silent saying and saying of a single name. Instructions on how to say Noellen: Insert flap N into slot O
RomanticMike Stone

Night Watch

Sometimes when I come to bed at night I watch you sleep, wrapped up So tightly in your blankets And you're so beautiful that
SadMike Stone

Is This It? #1

Is this how it all ends. Asking less and less from life. Hearing little of the sounds around you. Saying less or nothing at all.