Closeted — Poem analysis

Dave BontaRomantic

shut up in my little closet a wing your desiring mouth

who makes me stand so much that I am ashamed to dance

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Five short lines, no punctuation, and a title that works as both a place and a condition: "Closeted." Dave Bonta's poem is about a speaker who is hidden away, who is wanted by someone else, and who feels that being wanted has made them unable to move freely. Its central idea is that desire can be a kind of confinement. The speaker is tucked inside a private space, and shame stands between that space and the open floor where a body might dance.

The title is the first thing to read closely. A closet is a literal cupboard, and the poem opens by putting us inside one: "shut up in my little closet." The phrase "closeted" also carries the older, more charged sense of someone who keeps a part of themselves secret. The poem never says which meaning it intends, and I think it wants both. Judging by the shame in the last line, the secret is at least partly about desire. The word "little" shrinks the space and makes it faintly childlike, while "shut up" means both enclosed and silenced. The speaker is boxed in and told to be quiet in a single phrase.

Then comes the strangest line, "a wing," which sits alone and is the shortest in the poem. Syllable by syllable the lines run roughly eight, two, five, six, seven, so the poem pinches down to this one image and then slowly widens again. A wing is an odd thing to find in a closet. It might belong to a bird or a moth, or to something angelic. It might even be a part of the speaker's own body, folded away. Whatever it is, it suggests the capacity for flight kept in a space with no room to use it. The poem gives no verb and no explanation, so the image stays vivid and unsettled. The line break after "closet" also lets the wing seem to be pressed against the wall of the sentence it interrupts.

"Your desiring mouth" completes the opening sequence, and the three fragments sit side by side with nothing joining them. We never learn whether the mouth is outside the closet door, inside it, or the very thing that put the speaker there. The word "mouth" is well chosen. It is where speech and kissing both happen, so it ties to the silencing in "shut up" while promising its opposite. The participle "desiring" is active and ongoing, and it belongs to the other person. The speaker is the one acted upon.

The second part opens with "who," which has no clear antecedent. It could refer to the mouth, to the "you" behind it, or loosely to the whole situation. That grammatical looseness matches the speaker's sense of being pushed around by forces they can't quite name. "Makes me stand so much" is deliberately awkward. "Stand" can mean to endure or put up with, and it can also mean to be upright and stiff, which is the opposite of dancing. Both readings lead to the final line, "that I am ashamed to dance."

The sound of the poem supports this. Soft, hushed consonants run through it: "shut," "closet," "desiring," "stand," "so," "ashamed." The "sh" of "shut" returns in "ashamed," as if the shame were already contained in the first word. "Stand" and "dance" nearly chime, sharing a short *a* and a closing alveolar sound, yet they mean opposite things, rigid stillness against free movement. There is no rhyme or regular meter, and the free-verse looseness feels right for a speaker too self-conscious to move to a beat.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it trusts the reader. It names no gender, no relationship and no cause for the shame. It gives us a cupboard, a wing, a mouth and a refusal to dance, and it lets us assemble the story. The result is both intimate and open-ended. A reader can take it as a poem about concealed identity, or about the awkward self-consciousness of being desired, or about any longing that has made someone smaller than they want to be. In either case the last line lands with real force: shame has taken away the speaker's freedom of movement, and the wing is still folded in the dark.

Read also

More by Dave Bonta

All poems
ContemplativeDave Bonta

Plea bargain

I hear half a beat of drum to serve time have half a hope in the meantime praise God
DreamyDave Bonta

Cibola 3

I awake in the dark and shake free of sheets & blankets, of down-filled quilt. The rituals of waking– the long, hot shower, the coffee–give
ContemplativeDave Bonta

In good light

On a maple’s pale bark, a zigzag ladder—old tooth-marks from a wandering snail? Green islands of moss