The Summer Rain — Poem analysis

My books I'd fain cast off, I cannot read, 'Twixt every page my thoughts go stray at large Down in the meadow, where is richer feed, And will not mind to hit their proper targe. Plutarch was good, and so was Homer too, Our Shakespeare's life were rich to live again, What Plutarch read, that was not good nor true, Nor Shakespeare's books, unless his books were men.

Here while I lie beneath this walnut bough, What care I for the Greeks or for Troy town, If juster battles are enacted now Between the ants upon this hummock's crown?

Bid Homer wait till I the issue learn, If red or black the gods will favor most, Or yonder Ajax will the phalanx turn, Struggling to heave some rock against the host.

Tell Shakespeare to attend some leisure hour, For now I've business with this drop of dew, And see you not, the clouds prepare a shower-- I'll meet him shortly when the sky is blue.

This bed of herd's grass and wild oats was spread Last year with nicer skill than monarchs use. A clover tuft is pillow for my head, And violets quite overtop my shoes.

And now the cordial clouds have shut all in, And gently swells the wind to say all's well; The scattered drops are falling fast and thin, Some in the pool, some in the flower-bell.

I am well drenched upon my bed of oats; But see that globe come rolling down its stem, Now like a lonely planet there it floats, And now it sinks into my garment's hem.

Drip drip the trees for all the country round, And richness rare distills from every bough; The wind alone it is makes every sound, Shaking down crystals on the leaves below.

For shame the sun will never show himself, Who could not with his beams e'er melt me so; My dripping locks--they would become an elf, Who in a beaded coat does gayly go.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Thoreau begins by throwing his books away, though with a book-lover's regret. "My books I'd fain cast off, I cannot read," he says, because his thoughts keep drifting "down in the meadow, where is richer feed." The grazing image turns the wandering mind into a grazing animal and the meadow into better pasture than the page. Plutarch, Homer and Shakespeare are granted their greatness, but with a sting: Shakespeare's books are worth reading only "unless his books were men." Writing matters, the speaker implies, as a record of living, and he would rather have the living itself.

What follows is the poem's best joke. Lying under a walnut bough, he finds the Trojan War going on at his feet. The ants on the "hummock's crown" fight "juster battles" than the Greeks and Trojans did, and he describes them in Homer's own vocabulary: a "phalanx," gods who favor "red or black" (presumably two colours of ant), and a lone "Ajax" straining "to heave some rock against the host." The tone is mock-heroic, but the mockery cuts both ways. The ants are made absurdly grand, yet he watches them with the full attention a reader gives an epic. There is also a neat irony here: he can see the ants as warriors only because he has read Homer. The books are not so much discarded as released into the grass.

Then comes the comic politeness of "Bid Homer wait" and "Tell Shakespeare to attend some leisure hour." The greatest writers in the language are treated like callers turned away at the door, because the speaker has "business with this drop of dew." The word "business" is wry, since his only work is lying still and looking.

The poem keeps lowering its viewpoint. His bed of "herd's grass and wild oats" was made "with nicer skill than monarchs use," the clover is his pillow, and the violets "overtop my shoes," which tells us how close to the ground he lies. When the rain arrives, the language softens. The clouds are "cordial," meaning warm and friendly (and perhaps hinting at a restoring drink, though that is only an inference), and the wind swells "to say all's well." The drops fall "fast and thin, / Some in the pool, some in the flower-bell," a line that spreads the rain evenly over the landscape.

The scale then shifts again. A single drop rolling down a stem becomes "a lonely planet," and in the next line it "sinks into my garment's hem." In four lines the poem moves from the cosmos to a patch of wet cloth. After this, sound takes over. "Drip drip" opens the ninth stanza, and the awkwardly inverted "The wind alone it is makes every sound" slows the line down, as if the speaker were holding his breath to listen. The rain "distills" richness from every bough and shakes down "crystals," so the wealth of monarchs is answered with water that looks like jewels.

The form is plain and relaxed. Ten quatrains rhyme ABAB, in mostly regular iambic pentameter that loosens now and then, much like a mind at ease. The diction has an old-fashioned, bookish flavor ("fain," "'Twixt," and "targe," an old word for a shield, which probably helps the rhyme with "large"). The poem therefore sounds literary even as it renounces literature. The last rhyme pair, "bough" and "below," matches more to the eye than the ear, a small roughness the poem does not worry about.

The ending is the most playful part. The sun "will never show himself," and the speaker scolds him, since sunbeams could never "melt me so" as the rain has. With his "dripping locks" he looks like an elf "in a beaded coat." He began as a reader and ends as a creature of the meadow, dressed in dew, and the beaded coat answers the monarchs' finery.

The poem matters because it argues for direct attention and acts out the argument. Readers who know Thoreau for *Walden* will recognize the idea that a small, closely observed piece of the world can be worth more than inherited authority. Here that idea arrives with humor and without sermonizing, and it leaves Homer and Shakespeare enriching the afternoon rather than being cast off.

Read also

More by Henry David Thoreau

All poems
ContemplativeHenry David Thoreau

Prayer

Great God, I ask for no meaner pelf Than that I may not disappoint myself, That in my action I may soar as high As I can now discern with this clear eye.
ContemplativeHenry David Thoreau

The Moon

Time wears her not; she doth his chariot guide; Mortality below her orb is placed. --Raleigh The full-orbed moon with unchanged ray
SadHenry David Thoreau

I am the autumnal sun

Sometimes a mortal feels in himself Nature -- not his Father but his Mother stirs within him, and he becomes immortal with her immortality. From time to time she claims