Seeing the mist again — Poem analysis

Feng YanDreamy

I did not hear my childhood nickname When smoke rose from kitchen chimney Beside lake in foreign land Willow trees embankment, sun setting

Birds song heard as curling smoke was rising Smoke floating, drifting, as if from depths of my heart Going near and far, then lost without trace.

My steps cannot catch dispersing smoke Only my eyes can follow It is like dawn waiting for birds to wake. Secretly I call my nickname But cannot go back to my childhood

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

The most important event in Feng Yan's poem is something that does not happen. In the first line the speaker says, "I did not hear my childhood nickname," and everything after grows out of that silence. The scene itself is ordinary: smoke rising from a kitchen chimney, a lake, willows along an embankment, the sun going down. The phrase "foreign land" explains why it hurts. Kitchen smoke suggests a meal, a household, perhaps a child being called in at dusk. The speaker stands outside that picture, listening for a name that belongs to another place and time. The poem is about homesickness, but more exactly about the gap between the adult who stands here and the child who once answered to that nickname.

The construction is quiet and spare. This is free verse, with no rhyme and no regular line length. The stanzas run four, three and five lines, and the shortest one, the middle stanza, ends with the smoke "lost without trace." The stanza shrinks as the smoke vanishes. In this English version the grammar is also stripped back: "Willow trees embankment, sun setting" and "Birds song heard as curling smoke was rising" drop their small connecting words. The effect is telegraphic, like notes jotted by someone who can only take in what the eye catches and cannot explain it.

Smoke is the poem's central image, and the poem keeps changing what it means. At first it is a plain sign of other people's homes. Then comes the simile "as if from depths of my heart," which reverses the usual direction. The smoke does not remind the speaker of a feeling. The feeling seems to be producing the smoke. The verbs are soft and aimless: "curling," "floating, drifting," "dispersing." The line "Going near and far" holds two opposites at once, so the smoke cannot be pinned down. The title speaks of mist, while the poem speaks of smoke, and the two blend into one thing that can be seen but never held.

The poem also tracks the senses as they fail. In the first line the ear is disappointed, because the one sound the speaker wants never comes. In the second stanza hearing works, but it delivers the wrong sound, birdsong instead of a name. In the third the feet give up ("My steps cannot catch dispersing smoke") and "Only my eyes can follow." By the end the speaker is reduced to watching, which is the least active way of being present.

The most puzzling line is "It is like dawn waiting for birds to wake." The first stanza had a setting sun, and now it is morning. One reading is that time itself has loosened, so that evening and dawn, past and present, no longer stay apart. Another is that the line gives waiting a gentler shape. Dawn is patient and expects something to stir, as the speaker has been waiting for a call that never came. The poem does not decide between these, and the oddness of the comparison is part of its charm.

The ending answers the opening. Nobody calls the name, so the speaker does it alone: "Secretly I call my nickname." The word "secretly" makes the act private, almost embarrassed, like something an adult does not admit to. Then comes the flat "But cannot go back to my childhood." After so much drifting imagery, the last line offers no smoke or willow to soften it, only a plain statement. The poem does not end on a beautiful picture. It ends on a limit.

What makes the poem worth reading is how much it gets from so little. A nickname is usually the most intimate name we have, used mainly by people who knew us earliest, so its absence suggests that those people and that time are out of reach too. The poem never says this outright. It lets a thread of kitchen smoke carry the loss, and it shows how a very small, specific thing can stand for a feeling most readers will recognise.

Read also

More by Feng Yan

All poems
InspiredFeng Yan

Daughter of red wine

Daughter’s first cry, father’s heart overwhelmed Rice, grain by grain, panned and soaked Father uses hands rubbing warmth from glutinous rice Then buried deep, under Osmanthus fragrant tree