To HIM. — Poem analysis

Why did you say that? Why did you say those hurtful words? What did I do wrong? Did you care about me at all? If you say no to that question, Then all those text messages, All those facebook messages, The card from February 14th, Was a lie. A LIE. I can handle a lie. I’ve done that before. But from you, It will be harder. I thought you were different. I thought you wouldn’t hurt me. Looks like I was wrong. Again. You said to me, “I promise you I won’t run away.” Well. You broke your promise. You’re running away from me. To someone else. Someone you have already been with. A girl with another man’s baby in her. Did you even think? Did you even think about How your decisions affect others? Have you ever thought about others? And how your decisions affect them? Did you think about how I would feel? No. You didn’t. You only thought about your feelings. And how they were stronger with your past. It hurts me, So much, To be around you. You can’t even imagine How much I’m hurting from this. But I will never show you. I won’t give anyone The satisfaction Of seeing me weak. Vulnerable. Out of control. NEVER.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

Before the first line, the poem has already chosen its listener: «To HIM.» Everything that follows is a direct address, a confrontation staged on the page. The speaker has been left for another girl, one he has "already been with," who is pregnant by "another man." Nothing is known here about the writer beyond the screen name "super13HAPPY," so it is safest to read the voice as a speaker and let the text carry the story. The central idea is a contradiction. She insists she will never let anyone see her hurt, and yet the whole poem is that hurt on display.

The poem opens with a volley of questions: "Why did you say that? / Why did you say those hurtful words? / What did I do wrong?" They sound like a person who hasn't yet decided whether to plead or accuse. Then she builds a case like a lawyer, listing her evidence: "all those text messages, / All those facebook messages, / The card from February 14th." The details are ordinary and modern, which makes them feel real. A Facebook message and a Valentine's card are small things, but piled up they become a relationship's whole record, and she dares him to call it "a lie." The capitalised "A LIE." stands alone, a slammed door.

What follows is the most revealing moment. "I can handle a lie. / I've done that before." She tries to sound tough, but the admission slips out that she has been deceived in the past. "I thought you were different" and "Looks like I was wrong. / Again." make her pain a pattern, and his betrayal the one she hoped would never come. The single word "Again," cut off from the sentence before it, carries a weary history in very little space.

The poem's form does a lot of this work. It is free verse with no rhyme and no regular rhythm, built from short, plain, mostly one-beat lines. They read like speech, or like text messages typed in anger, which suits the subject. The line breaks work as pauses and gasps. "Well." is a whole line, dripping with sarcasm, placed right after his quoted promise: "I promise you I won't run away." The line is bitterly ironic because he does exactly that, running "to someone else." Her description of the rival, "A girl with another man's baby in her," is blunt and almost physical. She doesn't name the girl, and the phrasing reduces her to a situation, which suggests contempt, jealousy, or both.

Midway the questions harden into accusation. "Did you even think?" is repeated, then reshaped: "Have you ever thought about others?" The repetition has the circling quality of anger that can't stop rehearsing its grievance. Then she answers for him: "No. / You didn't." Notice that her sharpest insight is also her saddest. He "only thought about your feelings," which were "stronger with your past." She understands that she lost to history, not to a better rival.

The ending turns inward. "It hurts me, / So much" is where the poem is most exposed, followed by "You can't even imagine." But the pride returns at once: "I won't give anyone / The satisfaction / Of seeing me weak. / Vulnerable. / Out of control." These three fragments tighten like a fist, each word naming a fear. The last word, capitalised like "A LIE," is "NEVER." Her self-control is itself something of a performance, and the poem works because the reader can hear it straining.

That strain is what makes the poem worth reading. It captures a feeling many readers will recognise: the urge to hold your head up while falling apart. The capital letters, the one-word lines and the blunt questions don't hide the speaker's pain, they carry it. Its voice sounds young and unpolished, and that rawness is a strength, because nothing comes between the reader and the emotion. In vowing never to show her hurt, she writes it out in full, and the poem becomes the one place where she is allowed to be vulnerable.

Read also

More by super13HAPPY

All poems
Anxioussuper13HAPPY

Them

I feel so alone. So… out of place. He’s busy. He has no time for me.
Anxioussuper13HAPPY

I Wish

I wish you could see I wish you could know See what I see Know what I know
Contemplativesuper13HAPPY

Two

How is it that you know me? So well? You know when I’m happy. You know when I’m hurting.