«Why do you do these things to my heart?» — Poem analysis

deeRomantic

Why do you do these things to my heart? You pull me in and hold me close, And just when I've burned your image into my brain, You let go. Disappearing into the haze surrounding my thoughts- and for a while I don't know what to do. It's strange to not need someone and to need them all at once- To want to push them away and hold them close at the same time. It's true that things were never supposed to turn out this way, Friends, right? Always friends- who never admit the things we thought or said or breathed in hushed whispers over the phone lines because we were too afraid to be heard. Always friends- Sometimes I want nothing more, Than to be the one who has given you a reason to smile, Even if its the slightest quirk of your lips, That you try to hide beneath your fingertips, I want to be that one reason, That lone desert flower bursting through despite the heat- Or the sun- Or the sand. Despite it all, Despite all the reasons why it's wrong, Despite all the times you've turned me away, It still means everything to me, To have you utter one word, To greet me or- Two to ask me how I am or- Three to say everything that I once felt. Or still do. Who knows right? Because you're the epitome of a tumbleweed, You never stay, And just when I think I've caught you, You're gone again, But I don't mind it at all. I don't mind losing you, As long as somehow- You come back, You come back to me again.

Show the whole poemHide the poem

Learn Poems app

Try the Learn Poems app

Everything from the website trainer, and more: new exercises, voice recording and sharing, reminders, quick review.

A question opens the poem, and it never really gets answered: "Why do you do these things to my heart?" From there the speaker works through a pull-and-release cycle with someone who draws them close and then slips away. The poem's central idea is a contradiction the speaker cannot resolve. It is "strange to not need someone and to need them all at once," to want to "push them away and hold them close at the same time." Wrapped inside a supposed friendship, the feeling can't be named, so it comes out as longing, hedging and, finally, a kind of surrender.

The form suits that confusion. There is no rhyme scheme and no steady rhythm, and the lines vary wildly in length. "You let go." is three words and drops like a dropped hand. Then comes one long, breathless line about things "said or breathed in hushed whispers over the phone lines because we were too afraid to be heard." The sentence runs on without stopping, much like a whispered late-night call that no one wants to end. Hyphens trail at the ends of lines, so thoughts keep breaking off, as though the speaker keeps almost saying something and then thinks better of it. Sound patterns do appear, but quietly: "lips" and "fingertips" nearly rhyme, and "heat," "sun" and "sand" arrive in a rolling "or… or…" list that echoes the heaviness of the climate it describes.

The word "friends" is the poem's most interesting piece of vocabulary. It appears first as a question, "Friends, right?", and then as a repeated, flat "Always friends-". The tag question "right?" returns at "Who knows right?", and both times the speaker seems to be asking for agreement they don't believe in. The label is a safe place to hide, and the poem is partly about how tiring that hiding is. Notice also how the speaker gives the secret away: what they never admit is "the things we thought or said," and the "we" suggests the feeling may not be one-sided, though the poem never confirms this.

The imagery is small and tender at first. The speaker wants to be the reason behind "the slightest quirk of your lips, / That you try to hide beneath your fingertips." That is a close, observant detail, the kind only someone who watches very carefully would notice. Then the poem moves to the desert. The speaker imagines being a "lone desert flower bursting through despite the heat," and later calls the other person "the epitome of a tumbleweed." The two images share a landscape but are opposites. A flower is rooted and stays where it blooms, while a tumbleweed is a plant torn from its roots and blown wherever the wind goes. The speaker waits in place, and the beloved rolls past. It is a quietly funny word choice too, since "epitome" sounds almost dry and formal beside the ache around it.

The poem also counts. "One word" to greet, "Two to ask me how I am," "Three to say everything that I once felt." The third item names no words, but judging by the pattern, the unspoken three are the confession that never comes. The speaker's wants shrink as the list grows, from a smile to a greeting to a few syllables, which shows how little they are willing to settle for. Right after it comes the smallest line in the poem, "Or still do," which admits in four syllables that the feeling has not ended.

The closing lines are the most revealing. "I don't mind it at all. / I don't mind losing you" is contradicted by everything before it, since a speaker who truly didn't mind would not write the poem. The condition attached, "as long as somehow- / You come back," collapses into a repeated plea, "You come back, / You come back to me again." The ending echoes the opening pattern too. Early on, "just when I've burned your image into my brain, / You let go." Near the end, "just when I think I've caught you, / You're gone again." The poem has come full circle, and the speaker has chosen to stay in the circle.

What makes the poem worth reading is its honesty about a feeling people usually tidy up. It doesn't offer a lesson or an escape. It lets a speaker say "I don't mind" while plainly minding, and in doing so it captures how devotion can sound like calm when it is really hope.

Read also

More by dee

All poems
Romanticdee

First Love

I've tried to erase the image of you from my brain, I've tried a hundred times, To take the giant eraser of my mind, And erase,
Dreamydee

* * *

If I had just one wish ..I would be this small again, just for a day, Just to feel the world be so much bigger than me, To see the world as one big burst of color
Romanticdee

* * *

I wish, that I could carry you in my pocket all day, Like some little good luck charm,